The potential of dual-energy CT to reduce proton beam range uncertainties
- 21 April 2017
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Medical Physics
- Vol. 44 (6) , 2332-2344
Abstract
Dual-energy CT (DECT) promises improvements in estimating stopping power ratios (SPRs) for proton therapy treatment planning. Although several comparable mathematical formalisms have been proposed in literature, the optimal techniques to characterize human tissue SPRs with DECT in a clinical environment are not fully established. The aim of this work is to compare the most robust DECT methods against conventional single-energy CT (SECT) in conditions reproducing a clinical environment, where CT artifacts and noise play a major role on the accuracy of these techniques. Available DECT tissue characterization methods are investigated and their ability to predict SPRs is compared in three contexts: 1) a theoretical environment using XCOM cross sections database; 2) experimental data using a dual-source CT scanner on a calibration phantom; 3) simulations of a virtual humanoid phantom with the ImaSim software. The latter comparison accounts for uncertainties caused by CT artifacts and noise, but leaves aside other sources of uncertainties such as CT grid size and the I-values. To evaluate the clinical impact, a beam range calculation model is used to predict errors from the probability distribution functions determined with ImaSim simulations. Range errors cause by SPR errors in soft tissues and bones are investigated. Range error estimations demonstrate that DECT has the potential of reducing proton beam range uncertainties by 0.4% in soft tissues using low noise levels of 12 and 8 HU in DECT, corresponding to 7 HU in SECT. For range uncertainties caused by the transport of protons through bones, the reduction in range uncertainties for the same levels of noise is found to be up to 0.6 to 1.1 mm for bone thicknesses of ranging from 1 to 5 cm, respectively. We also show that for double the amount noise, i.e., 14 HU in SECT and 24 and 16 HU for DECT, the advantages of DECT in soft tissues are lost over SECT. However in bones, the reduction in range uncertainties is found to be between 0.5 and 0.9 mm for bone thicknesses ranging from 1 to 5 cm, respectively. DECT has a clear potential to improve proton beam range predictions over SECT in proton therapy. However, in the current state high levels of noise remain problematic for DECT characterization methods and do not allow getting the full benefits of this technology. Future work should focus on adapting DECT methods to noise and investigate methods based on raw-data to reduce CT artifacts.Keywords
Funding Information
- Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (20873)
- National Physical Laboratory
This publication has 28 references indexed in Scilit:
- Comprehensive analysis of proton range uncertainties related to patient stopping-power-ratio estimation using the stoichiometric calibrationPhysics in Medicine & Biology, 2012
- Range uncertainties in proton therapy and the role of Monte Carlo simulationsPhysics in Medicine & Biology, 2012
- Potential of dual‐energy subtraction for converting CT numbers to electron density based on a single linear relationshipMedical Physics, 2012
- Theoretical variance analysis of single- and dual-energy computed tomography methods for calculating proton stopping power ratios of biological tissuesPhysics in Medicine & Biology, 2010
- Dual-energy CT-based material extraction for tissue segmentation in Monte Carlo dose calculationsPhysics in Medicine & Biology, 2008
- Density and atomic number measurements with spectral x-ray attenuation methodJournal of Applied Physics, 2003
- The precision of proton range calculations in proton radiotherapy treatment planning: experimental verification of the relation between CT-HU and proton stopping powerPhysics in Medicine & Biology, 1998
- The calibration of CT Hounsfield units for radiotherapy treatment planningPhysics in Medicine & Biology, 1996
- Average soft-tissue and bone models for use in radiation dosimetryBritish Journal of Radiology, 1987
- The composition of body tissuesBritish Journal of Radiology, 1986