Comparison of three emergency department triage systems among Thai medical students: A randomized three-period crossover simulation study
Authors:
- Jarupa YaowalaorngJYJarupa Yaowalaorng
- Thanin LokeskraweeTLThanin Lokeskrawee
- Natthaphon PruksathornNPNatthaphon Pruksathorn
- Suppachai LawanaskolSuppachai Lawanaskol
- Jayanton PatumanondJPJayanton Patumanond
- Chanitda WichaCWChanitda Wicha
- Wanwisa BumrungpagdeeWBWanwisa Bumrungpagdee
- Suwapim ChanlaorSCSuwapim Chanlaor
Open Access
- 26 October 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 21 (10) , e0350690
Abstract
Introduction: In Thailand, the Emergency Severity Index (ESI) and Ministry of Public Health Emergency Department triage system (MOPH) are commonly used, whereas the Thai Rapid Initial Assessment and Grading for Emergency (TRIAGE) system has been newly proposed. Comparative evidence is limited. We compared correct triage as the primary outcome, with under-triage, over-triage, and completion time as secondary outcomes. Methods: We conducted a randomized three-period crossover simulation study at the Lampang Medical Education Center from October 2025 to January 2026. Fifth- and sixth-year medical students without recent standardized triage reinforcement classified 50 standardized patient cards per system in one of six sequences, with a one-week washout between periods. Multilevel mixed-effects models were used to estimate between-system differences, with adjustment for period, sequence, and academic year. Results: Sixty students completed all periods. No significant overall differences were detected in correct triage across TRIAGE, ESI, and MOPH (63.2%, 64.5%, and 61.8%, respectively), or in under-triage (19.6%, 20.0%, and 18.8%). Among sixth-year students, correct triage differed significantly across systems (global P = 0.004), with higher adjusted probabilities for ESI and TRIAGE than MOPH. Over-triage differed across systems and was highest with MOPH (7.0%), followed by TRIAGE (5.7%) and ESI (4.9%). Completion time was longest with TRIAGE (32.8 minutes), compared with ESI (24.3 minutes) and MOPH (23.2 minutes). Conclusion: No significant overall differences in correct or under-triage were detected, but the study was not powered to establish equivalence. MOPH showed higher over-triage, Completion time was longest with TRIAGE. Generalizability to experienced clinicians requires further study. Trial registration: Thai Clinical Trials Registry (TCTR) TCTR20260316003Keywords
Funding Information
- National Institute of Emergency Medicine
- Lampang Medical Education Center
This publication has 9 references indexed in Scilit:
- Machine Learning-Based Model to Classify Emergency Severity Index Levels 1-3 in Febrile Patients With Tachycardia: Thailand Triage Prediction SystemJournal of Clinical Medicine Research, 2025
- Comparison of the effectiveness of a serious game and pre-recorded lecture in diagnosis and treatment planning of oral lesions for dental studentsScientific Reports, 2024
- Retention of Critical Procedural Skills After Simulation Training: A Systematic ReviewAEM Education and Training, 2020
- Implementing a General Framework for Assessing Interrater Agreement in StataThe Stata Journal: Promoting communications on statistics and Stata, 2018
- Bonferroni‐based correction factor for multiple, correlated endpointsPharmaceutical Statistics, 2012
- Applied Longitudinal Analysis2011
- Moving from novice to expert – the value of learning in clinical practice: a literature reviewNurse Education Today, 2004
- Integration and generalization of kappas for multiple raters.Psychological Bulletin, 1980
- Multiple Comparisons among MeansJournal of the American Statistical Association, 1961