The purpose of this study was to observe college students' behavior on five multiple-choice, self-tailored exams of 75 items. Self-tailoring was defined as an option to omit up to five questions from being scored on an exam. Ninety-nine students from two sections of an undergraduate educational psychology course made a statistically significant increase in their mean scores on all exams by using the self-tailoring procedure. Students' efficacy in omitting incorrect answers on self-tailored tests was noted. There was a statistically significant linear increase in percent of incorrectly answered questions omitted from the total number of questions omitted in five exams. Frequency of questions omitted from scoring was statistically negatively correlated with their difficulty. Implications for assessment and teaching using self-tailored tests in college classrooms were mentioned.