Seeing Like a City: The Dialectic of Modern and Premodern Ways of Seeing in Urban Governance
- 25 May 2011
- journal article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Law & Society Review
- Vol. 45 (2) , 277-312
Abstract
Studies of urban governance, as well as the overlapping literature on law and space, have been heavily influenced by critical analyses of how spatial techniques helped constitute modern disciplinary powers and knowledges. The rise of land-use control and land-use planning seem at first sight to be perfect examples of the disciplining of populations through space by the kind of governmental gaze dubbed by Scott (1998) as “seeing like a state.” But a detailed genealogical study that puts the emergence of the notion of “land use” in the broader context of urban governance technologies reveals that modernist techniques of land use planning, such as North American zoning, are more flexible, contradictory, and fragile than critical urbanists assume. Legal tools of premodern origin that target nonquantifiable offensiveness and thus construct an embodied and relational form of urban subjectivity keep reappearing in the present day. When cities attempt to govern conflicts about the use of space through objective rules, these rules often undermine themselves in a dialectical process that results in the return to older notions of offensiveness. This article argues that the dialectical process by which modernist “seeing like a state” techniques give way to older ways of seeing (e.g., the logic of nuisance) plays a central role in the epistemologically hybrid approach to governing space that is here called “seeing like a city.”Keywords
This publication has 21 references indexed in Scilit:
- Calculating without numbers: aesthetic governmentality in Delhi's slumsEconomy and Society, 2010
- Jurisdiction and Scale: Legal `Technicalities' as Resources for TheorySocial & Legal Studies, 2009
- Authorizing the Production of Urban Moral Order: Appellate Courts and Their Knowledge GamesLaw & Society Review, 2005
- Far Beyond ‘The Early Morning Crowing of a Farmyard Cock’: Revisiting the Place of Nuisance within Legal and Political DiscourseSocial & Legal Studies, 2002
- Law's Territory (A History of Jurisdiction)Michigan Law Review, 1999
- Governed By Law?Social & Legal Studies, 1998
- Nuisance — the Environmental Tort? Hunter v Canary Wharf in the House of LordsThe Modern Law Review, 1998
- Toward a genealogy of planning: zoning and the Welfare StatePlanning Perspectives, 1998
- Political Power beyond the State: Problematics of GovernmentThe British Journal of Sociology, 1992
- Nuisance Law and the Industrial RevolutionThe Journal of Legal Studies, 1974