Collective payments for ecosystem services: a counterpart of commodification and privatization trends in nature conservation?
Authors:
- Josef KaiserJKJosef Kaiser
- Dagmar HaaseDHDagmar Haase
- Tobias KruegerTKTobias Krueger
Open Access
- 1 January 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Resilience Alliance, Inc. in Ecology and Society
- Vol. 28 (1)
Abstract
Payments for ecosystem services (PES) gained an increasing importance in science and politics within the last decades. Although the enthusiasm about PES is particularly high in Environmental Economics, opponents criticize the market-based character of PES and the associated commodification as well as privatization trends. By means of a systematic literature review we aim at shedding light on the complex and controversial debate about how to define commodification and related privatization processes and how they are linked to PES outcomes. We do so by setting a particular focus on the potentials and challenges of community-based and collective PES (C-PES), also in contrast to PES targeting land under private land tenure (P-PES). Our results reveal that C-PES show promising results when targeting local communities with a high level of social capital. However, there is a lack of studies that systematically assess the relations between different degrees of commodification and the ecological and social outcome of PES programs. For this reason, we provide a new conceptual framework of commodification by highlighting two interrelated spheres, where PES-related commodification processes take place: The first sphere relates to the commodification of ES-providing land, which greatly depends on the land tenure regime in place. The second sphere addresses the commodification of ecosystem services (ES). Our review indicates that C-PES show rather low degrees of commodification in the first sphere because the ES-providing land is often less embedded into private land markets. This is due to often missing alienation rights, more complex decision-making processes, and a potentially lower profit-orientation of the landowners. Empirical long-term studies are needed to investigate changes in both spheres of commodification over time, their potential interactions, and how they affect the outcome of C-PES and P-PES programs.Keywords
This publication has 121 references indexed in Scilit:
- The journal coverage of Web of Science and Scopus: a comparative analysisScientometrics, 2015
- Co-investment paradigms as alternatives to payments for tree-based ecosystem services in AfricaCurrent Opinion in Environmental Sustainability, 2014
- Problematizing REDD+ as an experiment in payments for ecosystem servicesCurrent Opinion in Environmental Sustainability, 2012
- Payment for Environmental Services: Interactions with Property Rights and Collective Action2012
- The Development of Payments for Ecosystem Services as a Community-Based Conservation Strategy in East Africa2011
- Payments for ecosystem services as commodity fetishismEcological Economics, 2010
- Payments for environmental services in Costa RicaEcological Economics, 2008
- Designing payments for environmental services in theory and practice: An overview of the issuesEcological Economics, 2008
- Reconciling sustainability, systems theory and discountingEcological Economics, 2007
- Payments for environmental services in watersheds: Insights from a comparative study of three cases in Central AmericaEcological Economics, 2007