Nocturnal haemodialysis: An Australian cost comparison with conventional satellite haemodialysis (Review Article)
Authors:
- 22 November 2005
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Nephrology
- Vol. 10 (6) , 557-570
Abstract
Dialysis is an expensive therapy, particularly considering its recurrent, protracted nature while patient numbers are also increasing. To afford dialysis for those in need, smarter, more efficient use of limited funds is mandatory. Newer techniques and improved equipment now permit safe, highly effective haemodialysis (HD) at home, alone and while asleep. Indeed, the increase in treatment hours and frequency achieved through nocturnal HD both increase HD efficiency and reduce cardiovascular stress when comparing nocturnal HD (6 nights/week for 8 h/treatment) to conventional daytime HD (4 h/treatment, three times/week). This study compares the expenditure of two distinct HD programmes in the same renal service during the Australian financial year 2003/2004. A conventional satellite HD unit (SHDU) and a nocturnal home HD programme (NHHD(6)) are compared, with both programmes 'notionalised' to 30 patients. The state-derived funding models under which these programmes operate are explained. All wage costs, recurrent expenditure, fixed costs and the estimated costs of building and infrastructure are included. The total NHHD(6) programme expenditure was 33,392 Australian dollars/patient per year (103.82 Australian dollars/treatment) and was 3,892 Australian dollars/patient per year less (a 10.75% saving) when compared with the SHDU expenditure of 36,284 Australian dollars/patient per year (232.58 Australian dollars/treatment). This represented an annual 116,750 Australian dollars programme saving for a 30 patient cohort. Potential additional NHHD(6) savings in erythropoietin, hospitalization and social security dependence were also identified. Home-based therapies are clinically sound, effective and fiscally prudent and efficient. Funding models should reward home-based HD. Health services should encourage home training and support systems, sustaining patients at home wherever possible.Keywords
This publication has 15 references indexed in Scilit:
- Nocturnal haemodialysis in Australia and New Zealand (Review Article)Nephrology, 2005
- Nocturnal Hemodialysis in AustraliaHemodialysis International, 2003
- Preventing end-stage renal disease: the potential impact of screening and intervention in developing countriesNephrology Dialysis Transplantation, 2003
- Cost savings of home nocturnal versus conventional in-center hemodialysisKidney International, 2002
- LDL MODULATES GROWTH RESPONSES IN HUMAN PROXIMAL TUBULAR CELLS (PTC)Nephrology, 2002
- Nightly Home Hemodialysis in Lynchburg, Virginia: Economic and Logistic ConsiderationsSeminars in Dialysis, 1999
- Survival as an index of adequacy of dialysisKidney International, 1992
- Control of Hypertension and Prolonged Survival on Maintenance HemodialysisNephron, 1983
- HEMODIALYSIS IN THE HOMEASAIO Journal, 1965
- Hemodialysis in the HomeJAMA, 1964