They Can’t All Be Stars: The Matthew Effect, Cumulative Status Bias, and Status Persistence in NBA All-Star Elections
Open Access
- 22 March 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in American Sociological Review
- Vol. 88 (2) , 189-219
Abstract
This study investigates the extent to and mechanisms through which Matthew effects create persistent status hierarchies. We propose a model that highlights the role of cumulative status bias in the feedback loop that leads from initial status allocation to status confirmation. We investigate the formalized process of repeated status allocation in annual elections to the National Basketball Association (NBA) All-Star game. Using detailed records on player performances allows us to isolate the Matthew effect from actual productivity differences to show that a previous All-Star nomination improves the chances to be re-nominated. We demonstrate that this Matthew effect is partly explained by improved productivity after an All-Star nomination, but voters’ evaluations are also directly biased by a player’s prior status. Multiple previous nominations further improve a player’s chances, confirming the importance of cumulative status bias. The resulting status-biased persistence of achieved status implies ever greater decoupling of productivity and status, undermining the meritocratic allocation of status and resources even more than the existing literature acknowledges.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 57 references indexed in Scilit:
- Only 15 Minutes? The Social Stratification of Fame in Printed MediaAmerican Sociological Review, 2013
- Quantitative and empirical demonstration of the Matthew effect in a study of career longevityProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2010
- The Paradox of Meritocracy in OrganizationsAdministrative Science Quarterly, 2010
- Getting a Job: Is There a Motherhood Penalty?American Journal of Sociology, 2007
- The Institutionalization of Fame: Achievement, Recognition, and Cultural Consecration in BaseballAmerican Sociological Review, 2006
- Consensus and the Creation of Status BeliefsSocial Forces, 2006
- Creating and Spreading Status BeliefsAmerican Journal of Sociology, 2000
- Causal diagrams for empirical researchBiometrika, 1995
- Estimating Incumbency Advantage without BiasAmerican Journal of Political Science, 1990
- Cumulative Advantage and Inequality in ScienceAmerican Sociological Review, 1982