This work provides intriguing evidence that long-term recovery from depression associated with selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs) but not cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) reflects an underlying reduction in neuroticism, an individual's general sensitivity to stress and tendency to experience emotional distress and negative affect. In addition to the clinical implications, this work suggests that, rather than reflecting invariant aspects of the underlying neurobiology, personality can change as a function of changes in this neurobiology subsequent to pharmacological shifts in serotonin signaling. An important next step will be to map these patterns and trajectories onto changes in neurobiology using functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI).