Soldiers’ mutinies have undermined Nigeria’s counterterrorism efforts in the Northeast Region, despite repeated military denials of this. Although research on Nigeria’s counterterrorism operations is extensive, studies on the causes (poor welfare, inadequate weapons, sabotage) and effects (low morale, loss of territory, breakdown of command) of these mutinies remain limited. In particular, the implications of mutinies for national security, especially at the operational and tactical levels, have received little scholarly attention. By adopting a state-centric view of national security and drawing on secondary sources and key informant interviews, this study shows that frequent soldiers’ mutinies in the theatre of war have broad implications for Nigeria’s counterterrorism efforts and pose serious threats to national security. The study recommends genuine and concerted efforts in addressing soldiers’ grievances and complaints.