Is Fingerprint Identification Valid? Rhetorics of Reliability in Fingerprint Proponents’ Discourse
Author:
- 21 December 2005
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Law & Policy
- Vol. 28 (1) , 109-135
Abstract
Beginning around 1999, a growing number of scholars have claimed that validation studies for forensic fingerprint identification do not exist. This article revisits that claim by reviewing literature produced by proponents of fingerprint identification in response to that charge. It shows that fingerprint proponents employ rhetorical tricks in which they claim to address the validity question, but then subtly shift the question to ones that are easier to address. The article explores several different rhetorical strategies fingerprint proponents use to appear to be demonstrating validity, while in fact demonstrating other things. These include “the fingerprint examiner's fallacy” and “the casework fallacy.” The inability of fingerprint proponents to refute the charge that validity studies are lacking is further evidence that the charge is, in fact, correct.Keywords
This publication has 19 references indexed in Scilit:
- Daubert and the Exclusionary Ethos: The Convergence of Corporate and Judicial Attitudes towards the Admissibility of Expert Evidence in Tort Litigation*Law & Policy, 2004
- Forensic Science: Oxymoron?Science, 2003
- Questioning a Courtroom Proof of the Uniqueness of FingerprintsInternational Statistical Review, 2003
- Breaking the Waves in Science StudiesSocial Studies of Science, 2003
- Is Science Different for Lawyers?Science, 2002
- Scientific Ignorance and Reliable Patterns of Evidence in Toxic Tort Causation: Is There a Need for Liability Reform?Law and Contemporary Problems, 2001
- Commentary: Science at the Bar—Causes for ConcernScience, Technology, & Human Values, 1982
- The Admissibility of Novel Scientific Evidence: Frye v. United States, a Half-Century LaterColumbia Law Review, 1980
- Prenatal selection and dermatoglyphic patternsAmerican Journal of Physical Anthropology, 1978
- Early prenatal attainment of adult metacarpal‐phalangeal rankings and proportionsAmerican Journal of Physical Anthropology, 1975