A contribution for the evaluation of the territorial impact of transport infrastructures in the early stages of the EIA: application to the Huelva (Spain)–Faro (Portugal) rail link
- 25 February 2015
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Environmental Planning and Management
- Vol. 59 (2) , 302-319
Abstract
The Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) procedure should predict and identify the major impacts of a project development that may cause specific spatial and temporal effects. Early in the EIA, the scoping stage provides all the relevant information on the impacts of the project alternatives. In particular, potential effects on the territorial network such as habitat connectivity loss and accessibility improvements should be taken into account in the various proposed layout alternatives when evaluating transport infrastructure projects. However, several authors have identified deficiencies in practice. The aim of this article is to provide a methodology for the assessment of these territorial impacts using adequate indicators in the early stages of the EIA procedure. The proposed method is based on a comparison of a range of alternative layouts for a railway line linking two population centres, using indicators calculated with geographic information systems. The methodology was applied to a case study – the rail link between Huelva (Spain) and Faro (Portugal) – and the high speed rail (HSR) and conventional rail were evaluated in different layouts. The method was effective in spatially identifying significant impacts on accessibility improvements, which occurred closer to the cross border area. The conventional railway alternatives have similar accessibility values to the HSR. The results also reveal that connectivity loss is not limited to the area around the infrastructure, but extends throughout the territory. The results are at variance with the initiative proposed by Spanish and Portuguese transport decision-makers, and raise the possibility of selecting a conventional railway option. An adequate territorial evaluation methodology enables the new action to be correctly assessed, and supplies the information required to propose the most suitable alternative from a socio-economic and environmental standpoint, regardless of whether this proposal was initially included in the transport policy.Keywords
This publication has 48 references indexed in Scilit:
- The policy-relevancy of impact assessment tools: Evaluating nine years of European research fundingEnvironmental Science & Policy, 2013
- Spain: highs and lows of 20years of HSR operationJournal of Transport Geography, 2013
- Accessibility impacts of high-speed railJournal of Transport Geography, 2012
- UK and Italian EIA systems: A comparative study on management practice and performance in the construction industryEnvironmental Impact Assessment Review, 2012
- Evaluating the European added value of TEN-T projects: a methodological proposal based on spatial spillovers, accessibility and GISJournal of Transport Geography, 2011
- GIS-based approach for incorporating the connectivity of ecological networks into regional planningJournal for Nature Conservation, 2010
- Improving the practice of cumulative effects assessment in CanadaImpact Assessment and Project Appraisal, 2001
- Accessibility and Economic Development in EuropeRegional Studies, 1999
- The European high-speed train networkJournal of Transport Geography, 1996
- A note on two problems in connexion with graphsNumerische Mathematik, 1959