The Robustness of Mental Accounting Across 21 Countries
Authors:
- Giulia PrioloGiulia Priolo
- Federica StablumFSFederica Stablum
- Martina VacondioMVMartina Vacondio
- Simone D’AMbrogioSDSimone D’AMbrogio
- Marta CaserottiMCMarta Caserotti
- Beatrice ConteBCBeatrice Conte
- Prisca De RoniPRPrisca De Roni
- Hilda du PlooyHPHilda du Plooy
- Vivian D GrilloVGVivian D Grillo
- Libera Y MastromatteoLMLibera Y Mastromatteo
- Elisa TedaldiETElisa Tedaldi
- Filippo ToscanoFTFilippo Toscano
Open Access
- 10 July 2026
- journal article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Journal of Consumer Research
Abstract
First introduced four decades ago, the influential concept of mental accounting—how people mentally organize, evaluate, and track financial activities—posits that consumers often defy traditional economic rationality, treating money as non-fungible across discrete mental accounts. The present study provides the first large-scale test of the replicability and generalizability of mental accounting effects, using a sample of 5,589 participants from 21 countries. The results demonstrate that mental accounting effects are replicable, robust, and generalizable. Hierarchical Bayesian meta-analyses revealed a 100% replication rate for all tested scenarios, while unpooled analyses showed a 90.5% replication rate (133/147 effects). Further analyses indicated that mental accounting effects were weaker in lower-income countries than in higher-income countries. Multidimensional scaling suggested that mental accounting effects vary along three interpretable dimensions that reflect social context (individual vs. interactive decisions), decision perspective (deciding for self vs. other), and role in price determination (setting vs. evaluating prices). Across a diverse population and after controlling for multiple factors, the findings show that consumers make decisions based on mentally formed accounts that consistently diverge from their objective financial value.Keywords
This publication has 77 references indexed in Scilit:
- How financially fragile can households become? Household borrowing, the welfare state, and macroeconomic resilienceReview of Evolutionary Political Economy, 2023
- Effects of mental accounting on purchase decision processes: A systematic review and research agendaJournal of Consumer Behaviour, 2023
- Mental accounting of product returnsJournal of Consumer Psychology, 2023
- The Need for Synergy in Academic Policies: An Introduction to the Dialogue on Pre‐registrationJournal of Consumer Psychology, 2020
- Would You Like to Round Up and Donate the Difference? Roundup Requests Reduce the Perceived Pain of DonatingJournal of Consumer Psychology, 2018
- Mental Accounting and Economic Behaviour2017
- Goals and bracketing under mental accountingJournal of Economic Theory, 2016
- An information processing review of the subjective value of money and pricesJournal of Business Research, 2006
- A simple method for converting an odds ratio to effect size for use in meta-analysisStatistics in Medicine, 2000
- Mental accounting mattersJournal of Behavioral Decision Making, 1999