State-ownership of tobacco industry: a ‘fundamental conflict of interest’ or a ‘tremendous opportunity’ for tobacco control?
Authors:
- 4 August 2015
- journal article
- research article
- Published by BMJ in Tobacco Control
- Vol. 25 (4) , 367-372
Abstract
Despite state-owned tobacco companies (SOTCs) accounting for over 40% of global production, the significance of state-ownership for tobacco control strategies has received limited academic and policy attention. The complex interests associated with SOTCs present diverse challenges for tobacco control policy, particularly in implementing Article 5.3 of WHO's Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (FCTC). Based on a review of existing literature, this paper examines current challenges and potential opportunities presented by governmental participation in the tobacco industry, identifying three contrasting perspectives from academic and policy sources. The first two perspectives centre on recognising that economic interests inherent in an SOTC are in tension with a government's public health responsibilities. This conflict can be perceived as either fundamental and fixed (‘intrinsic conflict’) or as amenable to either exacerbation or amelioration via organisational mechanisms (‘institutionally-mediated conflict’)—as suggested by the contrasting examples of China and Thailand. A third, less prominent perspective (which we refer to as ‘interest alignment’) suggests that it may be possible to radically alter the objectives and behaviour of SOTCs in order to advance tobacco control. Finally, we draw on this analysis to consider policy options for advancing tobacco control in countries with SOTCs. Guidance on implementation of Article 5.3 demonstrates strategic ambiguity by including elements of all three perspectives described above. We argue that legislative separation of tobacco control from SOTC oversight provides a desirable alternative to industry privatisation, and that radically realigning the goals of SOTCs to reduce tobacco consumption could make an important contribution to endgame strategies.Keywords
This publication has 32 references indexed in Scilit:
- A review of the impacts of tobacco industry privatisation: Implications for policyGlobal Public Health, 2011
- Implementation of the WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco Control in mainland ChinaTobacco Control, 2011
- Public health, corporations and the New Responsibility Deal: promoting partnerships with vectors of disease?Journal of Public Health, 2011
- Imagining things otherwise: new endgame ideas for tobacco controlTobacco Control, 2010
- The International Monetary Fund and Tobacco: A Product like Any Other?International Journal of Health Services, 2009
- Industrial epidemics, public health advocacy and the alcohol industry: lessons from other fieldsAddiction, 2007
- “The law was actually drafted by us but the Government is to be congratulated on its wise actions”: British American Tobacco and public policy in Kenya: Table 1Tobacco Control, 2007
- Tobacco in History2005
- Tobacco and transition: an overview of industry investments, impact and influence in the former Soviet Union: Table 6Tobacco Control, 2004
- International issues in the supply of tobacco: recent changes and implications for alcoholAddiction, 2000