Doctors and Patients’ Susceptibility to Framing Bias: A Randomized Trial
- 27 July 2011
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of General Internal Medicine
- Vol. 26 (12) , 1411-1417
Abstract
Framing of risk influences the perceptions of treatment benefit. To determine which risk framing format corresponds best to comprehensive multi-faceted information, and to compare framing bias in doctors and in patients. Randomized mail surveys. One thousand four hundred and thirty-one doctors (56% response rate) and 1121 recently hospitalized patients (65% response rate). Respondents were asked to interpret the results of a hypothetical clinical trial comparing an old and a new drug. They were randomly assigned to the following framing formats: absolute survival (new drug: 96% versus old drug: 94%), absolute mortality (4% versus 6%), relative mortality reduction (reduction by a third) or all three (fully informed condition). The new drug was reported to cause more side-effects. Rating of the new drug as more effective than the old drug. The proportions of doctors who rated the new drug as more effective varied by risk presentation format (abolute survival 51.8%, absolute mortality 68.3%, relative mortality reduction 93.8%, and fully informed condition 69.8%, p < 0.001). In patients these proportions were similar (abolute survival 51.7%, absolute mortality 66.8%, relative mortality reduction 89.3%, and fully informed condition 71.2%, p < 0.001). In both doctors (p = 0.72) and patients (p = 0.23) the fully informed condition was similar to the absolute risk format, but it differed significantly from the other conditions (all p < 0.01). None of the differences between doctors and patients were significant (all p > 0.1). In comparison to the fully informed condition, the odds ratio of greater perceived effectiveness was 0.45 for absolute survival (p < 0.001), 0.89 for absolute mortality (p = 0.29), and 4.40 for relative mortality reduction (p < 0.001). Framing bias affects doctors and patients similarly. Describing clinical trial results as absolute risks is the least biased format, for both doctors and patients. Presenting several risk formats (on both absolute and relative scales) should be encouraged.Keywords
This publication has 27 references indexed in Scilit:
- Informing PatientsMedical Decision Making, 2010
- What doctors think about the impact of managed care tools on quality of care, costs, autonomy, and relations with patientsBMC Health Services Research, 2010
- Does Prevalence Matter to Physicians in Estimating Post-test Probability of Disease? A Randomized TrialJournal of General Internal Medicine, 2010
- Patient-reported conformity of informed consent procedures and participation in clinical researchQJM: An International Journal of Medicine, 2010
- The Effect of How Outcomes Are Framed on Decisions about Whether to Take Antihypertensive Medication: A Randomized TrialPLOS ONE, 2010
- The Effect of Alternative Summary Statistics for Communicating Risk Reduction on Decisions about Taking Statins: A Randomized TrialPLOS Medicine, 2009
- The influence of types of decision support on physicians' decision makingArchives of Disease in Childhood, 2009
- Communicating effectiveness of intervention for chronic diseases: what single format can replace comprehensive information?BMC Medical Informatics and Decision Making, 2008
- The Ethics of Information: Absolute Risk Reduction and Patient Understanding of ScreeningJournal of General Internal Medicine, 2008
- A Meta-analysis of the Effects of Presenting Treatment Benefits in Different FormatsMedical Decision Making, 2007