Evaluating conservation biology texts for bias in biodiversity representation
Open Access
- 10 July 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 15 (7) , e0234877
Abstract
A critical component of textbooks is fair representation of the material they cover. Within conservation biology, fair coverage is particularly important given Earth’s breadth of species and diversity of ecosystems. However, research on species tends to be biased towards certain taxonomic groups and geographic areas and their associated ecosystems, so it is possible that textbooks may exhibit similar biases. Considering the possibility of bias, our goal was to evaluate contemporary conservation biology textbooks to determine if they are representative of Earth’s biodiversity. We found that textbooks did not accurately reflect Earth’s biodiversity. Species, ecosystems, and continents were unevenly represented, few examples mentioned genetic diversity, and examples of negative human influence on the environment outweighed positive examples. However, in terms of aquatic versus terrestrial representation, textbooks presented a representative sample. Our findings suggest that modern conservation biology textbooks are biased in their coverage, which could have important consequences for educating our next generation of scientists and practitioners.Keywords
This publication has 17 references indexed in Scilit:
- The biodiversity of species and their rates of extinction, distribution, and protectionScience, 2014
- Representation of herpetofauna in wildlife research journalsThe Journal of Wildlife Management, 2012
- Human bias and the biodiversity knowledge base: An examination of the published literature on vertebratesBiodiversity, 2009
- Global Biodiversity Conservation PrioritiesScience, 2006
- What do conservation biologists publish?Biological Conservation, 2005
- Taxonomic bias in reintroduction projectsAnimal Conservation, 2005
- Taxonomic Bias in Conservation ResearchScience, 2002
- A Primer of Conservation Biology.Journal of Applied Ecology, 1996
- Taxonomy of taxonomistsNature, 1992
- Changing Learner Behavior Through Environmental EducationThe Journal of Environmental Education, 1990