Technological difficulties: a theoretical frame for understanding the non‐relativistic permanence of traditional print literacy in elementary education
- 1 April 2006
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Curriculum Studies
- Vol. 38 (2) , 135-159
Abstract
Currently, definitions of ‘science’, ‘reading’, and ‘literacy’ in the US lend a seemingly non‐relativistic permanence to these terms, and render them resistant to critique. This paper offers a theoretical frame for critiquing this permanence, analysing why early‐literacy instruction is tightly tied to traditional forms of print literacy, focusing primarily on phonics and word‐recognition, in an age when new technologies, multi‐modal texts, and new literacies flourish. The theoretical framework uses Foucault’s notions of technologies of production, of sign systems, of power, and of the self. Four specific examples of early‐literacy programming are analysed in terms of Foucault’s technologies, producing an outline of reasoning about ‘best practices’ in early‐literacy instruction in the US. These ways of reasoning are investigated as relative, impermanent, and possibly open to change.Keywords
This publication has 7 references indexed in Scilit:
- Signs of the times: The governance of alphabetic print over ‘appropriate’ and ‘natural’ reading developmentJournal of Early Childhood Literacy, 2006
- LITERACY IN THE NEW MEDIA AGE2003
- Adolescence Lost/Childhood Regained: on Early Intervention and the Emergence of the Techno-SubjectJournal of Early Childhood Literacy, 2001
- Reading and Writing “Hypertextually”: Children’s Literature, Technology, and Early Writing InstructionLanguage Arts, 2001
- Space Between Words1997
- KNOWLEDGE AT THE CROSSROADS: SOME ALTERNATIVE FUTURES OF HYPERTEXT LEARNING ENVIRONMENTS*Educational Theory, 1996
- First Graders' Concepts about PrintReading Research Quarterly, 1980