Deliberative democracy and the politics of traditional leadership in South Africa: A case of despotic domination or democratic deliberation?
Authors:
- 1 April 2009
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Contemporary African Studies
- Vol. 27 (2) , 201-223
Abstract
A heated debate developed in South Africa as to the meaning of ‘deliberative democracy’. This debate is fanned by the claims of ‘traditional leaders’ that their ways of village-level deliberation and consensus-oriented decision-making are not only a superior process for the African continent as it evolves from pre-colonial tradition, but that it represents a form of democracy that is more authentic than the Western version. Proponents suggest that traditional ways of deliberation are making a come-back because imported Western models of democracy that focus on the state and state institutions miss the fact that in African societies state institutions are often seen as illegitimate or simply absent from people's daily lives. In other words, traditional leadership structures are more appropriate to African contexts than their Western rivals. Critics suggest that traditional leaders, far from being authentic democrats, are power-hungry patriarchs and authoritarians attempting to both re-invent their political, social and economic power (frequently acquired under colonial and apartheid rule) and re-assert their control over local-level resources at the expense of the larger community. In this view, the concept of deliberative democracy is being misused as a legitimating device for a politics of patriarchy and hierarchy, which is the opposite of the meaning of the term in the European and US sense. This article attempts to contextualise this debate and show how the efforts by traditional leaders to capture an intermediary position between rural populations and the state is fraught with conflicts and contradictions when it comes to forming a democratic state and society in post-apartheid South Africa.Keywords
This publication has 19 references indexed in Scilit:
- ‘Model Tribes’ and Iconic Conservationists? The Makuleke Restitution Case in Kruger National ParkDevelopment and Change, 2008
- The inequality of social capital and the reproduction of chronic povertyWorld Development, 2005
- Chiefs in South Africa2005
- Ubu and Ubuntu: On the dialectics of apartheid and nation buildingPolitikon, 2002
- NGOs, 'Bushmen' and Double Vision: The p khomani San Land Claim and the Cultural Politics of 'Community' and 'Development' in the KalahariJournal of Southern African Studies, 2001
- 'ONE CHIEF, ONE VOTE': THE REVIVAL OF TRADITIONAL AUTHORITIES IN POST-APARTHEID SOUTH AFRICAAfrican Affairs, 1997
- The crosscurrents of ethnicity and class in the construction of public policyAmerican Ethnologist, 1997
- ‘From confusion to Lusaka’: the youth revolt in SekhukhunelandJournal of Southern African Studies, 1993
- Language and Political EconomyAnnual Review of Anthropology, 1989
- The social space and the genesis of groupsSocial Science Information, 1985