The Legacy of ‘Solidarity’: Class, Democracy, Culture and Subjectivity in the Polish Social Movement
- 1 December 2005
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Social Movement Studies
- Vol. 4 (3) , 261-280
Abstract
The sociological debate on the nature of Solidarity, and its legacy for social mobilization in today's Poland, are assessed through secondary research as well as primary research on Polish social movements in 1995–2001. The three classic interpretations of Solidarity (class, democracy and nation) are discussed, and two conclusions are reached to overcome the ‘class versus intellectuals’ dispute. First, against cultural and political interpretations, a class interpretation is appropriate although not exclusive and not in a classic Marxist sense. Second, a fourth element, subjectivity, needs to be added to understand the rare combination of egalitarianism and individualism in Solidarity. The class and the subjective elements derive from the double nature of Polish society: industrial and ‘vocationally’ (not factually) totalitarian. The implication is that social mobilization in Poland can be expected primarily in labour activism and marginal cultural movements.Keywords
This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit:
- Short Circuits in Multinational Companies: The Extension of European Works Councils to PolandEuropean Journal of Industrial Relations, 2004
- The Trojan Horse for the Americanization of Europe? Polish Industrial Relations towards the EUEuropean Journal of Industrial Relations, 2002
- The Weakness of Strong Social Movements: Models of Unionism in the East European ContextEuropean Journal of Industrial Relations, 2002
- Challenging the State-socialist Order: a New Social Movement in PolandEast European Politics and Societies, 2001
- Unionists against Unions: toward Hierarchical Management in Post-communist PolandEast European Politics and Societies, 1998
- Creating Solidarity: the Religious Foundations of the Polish Social MovementEast European Politics and Societies, 1997
- Desperately seeking capitalism: Solidarity and Polish industrial relations in the 1990sIndustrial Relations Journal, 1995
- Who done it: Workers, intellectuals, or someone else? Controversy over Solidarity's origins and social compositionTheory and Society, 1994
- Mass Social Movements and Social ClassInternational Sociology, 1993
- Action, movement, and intervention: Reflections on the sociology of Alain TouraineCanadian Review of Sociology/Revue canadienne de sociologie, 1991