Truth and memory: Linking instantaneous and retrospective self-reported cigarette consumption
Open Access
- 1 December 2012
- journal article
- Published by Institute of Mathematical Statistics in The Annals of Applied Statistics
- Vol. 6 (4) , 1689-1706
Abstract
Studies of smoking behavior commonly use the time-line follow-back (TLFB) method, or periodic retrospective recall, to gather data on daily cigarette consumption. TLFB is considered adequate for identifying periods of abstinence and lapse but not for measurement of daily cigarette consumption, thanks to substantial recall and digit preference biases. With the development of the hand-held electronic diary (ED), it has become possible to collect cigarette consumption data using ecological momentary assessment (EMA), or the instantaneous recording of each cigarette as it is smoked. EMA data, because they do not rely on retrospective recall, are thought to more accurately measure cigarette consumption. In this article we present an analysis of consumption data collected simultaneously by both methods from 236 active smokers in the pre-quit phase of a smoking cessation study. We define a statistical model that describes the genesis of the TLFB records as a two-stage process of mis-remembering and rounding, including fixed and random effects at each stage. We use Bayesian methods to estimate the model, and we evaluate its adequacy by studying histograms of imputed values of the latent remembered cigarette count. Our analysis suggests that both mis-remembering and heaping contribute substantially to the distortion of self-reported cigarette counts. Higher nicotine dependence, white ethnicity and male sex are associated with greater remembered smoking given the EMA count. The model is potentially useful in other applications where it is desirable to understand the process by which subjects remember and report true observations.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit:
- How many cigarettes did you smoke? Assessing cigarette consumption by global report, time-line follow-back, and ecological momentary assessment.Health Psychology, 2009
- Modeling heaping in self‐reported cigarette countsStatistics in Medicine, 2008
- Multiple Imputation for Model Checking: Completed‐Data Plots with Missing and Latent DataBiometrics, 2005
- A mixture model for rounded dataJournal of the Royal Statistical Society: Series D (The Statistician), 2003
- Reducing tobacco harm: Research challenges and issuesNicotine & Tobacco Research, 2002
- Tobacco harm reduction: Conceptual structure and nomenclature for analysis and researchNicotine & Tobacco Research, 2002
- Digit preference in estimated gestational ageStatistics in Medicine, 1992
- Ignorability and Coarse DataThe Annals of Statistics, 1991
- Inference from Coarse Data via Multiple Imputation with Application to Age HeapingJournal of the American Statistical Association, 1990
- Bayesianly Justifiable and Relevant Frequency Calculations for the Applied StatisticianThe Annals of Statistics, 1984