Comparing the cost-effectiveness of simulation modalities: a case study of peripheral intravenous catheterization training
- 1 June 2013
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Advances in Health Sciences Education
- Vol. 19 (2) , 219-232
Abstract
While the ultimate goal of simulation training is to enhance learning, cost-effectiveness is a critical factor. Research that compares simulation training in terms of educational- and cost-effectiveness will lead to better-informed curricular decisions. Using previously published data we conducted a cost-effectiveness analysis of three simulation-based programs. Medical students (n = 15 per group) practiced in one of three 2-h intravenous catheterization skills training programs: low-fidelity (virtual reality), high-fidelity (mannequin), or progressive (consisting of virtual reality, task trainer, and mannequin simulator). One week later, all performed a transfer test on a hybrid simulation (standardized patient with a task trainer). We used a net benefit regression model to identify the most cost-effective training program via paired comparisons. We also created a cost-effectiveness acceptability curve to visually represent the probability that one program is more cost-effective when compared to its comparator at various ‘willingness-to-pay’ values. We conducted separate analyses for implementation and total costs. The results showed that the progressive program had the highest total cost (p < 0.001) whereas the high-fidelity program had the highest implementation cost (p < 0.001). While the most cost-effective program depended on the decision makers’ willingness-to-pay value, the progressive training program was generally most educationally- and cost-effective. Our analyses suggest that a progressive program that strategically combines simulation modalities provides a cost-effective solution. More generally, we have introduced how a cost-effectiveness analysis may be applied to simulation training; a method that medical educators may use to investment decisions (e.g., purchasing cost-effective and educationally sound simulators).Keywords
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- Technology-Enhanced Simulation for Health Professions EducationJAMA, 2011
- Coordinating Progressive Levels of Simulation Fidelity to Maximize Educational BenefitAcademic Medicine, 2010
- Cost Savings From Reduced Catheter-Related Bloodstream Infection After Simulation-Based Education for Residents in a Medical Intensive Care UnitSimulation in Healthcare: The Journal of the Society for Simulation in Healthcare, 2010
- One Drop at a Time: Research to Advance the Science of SimulationSimulation in Healthcare: The Journal of the Society for Simulation in Healthcare, 2010
- Using and interpreting cost-effectiveness acceptability curves: an example using data from a trial of management strategies for atrial fibrillationBMC Health Services Research, 2006
- Using the net benefit regression framework to construct cost-effectiveness acceptability curves: an example using data from a trial of external loop recorders versus Holter monitoring for ambulatory monitoring of "community acquired" syncopeBMC Health Services Research, 2006
- Assessing procedural skills in context: exploring the feasibility of an Integrated Procedural Performance Instrument (IPPI)Medical Education, 2006
- Cost‐effectiveness acceptability curves – facts, fallacies and frequently asked questionsHealth Economics, 2004
- Evaluation Roots2004
- Something old, something new, something borrowed, something blue: a framework for the marriage of health econometrics and cost‐effectiveness analysisHealth Economics, 2002