Application of Artificial Intelligence in Community-Based Primary Health Care: Systematic Scoping Review and Critical Appraisal
Authors:
- Samira Abbasgholizadeh RahimiSRSamira Abbasgholizadeh Rahimi
- France LégaréFLFrance Légaré
- Gauri SharmaGSGauri Sharma
- Patrick ArchambaultPAPatrick Archambault
- Herve Tchala Vignon ZomahounHZHerve Tchala Vignon Zomahoun
- Sam ChandavongSCSam Chandavong
- Nathalie RheaultNRNathalie Rheault
- Sabrina T WongSWSabrina T Wong
- Lyse LangloisLLLyse Langlois
- Yves CouturierYCYves Couturier
- Jose L SalmeronJose L Salmeron
- Marie-Pierre GagnonMGMarie-Pierre Gagnon
Top Cited Papers
Open Access
- 3 September 2021
- journal article
- review article
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in Journal of Medical Internet Research
- Vol. 23 (9) , e29839
Abstract
Background: Research on the integration of artificial intelligence (AI) into community-based primary health care (CBPHC) has highlighted several advantages and disadvantages in practice regarding, for example, facilitating diagnosis and disease management, as well as doubts concerning the unintended harmful effects of this integration. However, there is a lack of evidence about a comprehensive knowledge synthesis that could shed light on AI systems tested or implemented in CBPHC. Objective: We intended to identify and evaluate published studies that have tested or implemented AI in CBPHC settings. Methods: We conducted a systematic scoping review informed by an earlier study and the Joanna Briggs Institute (JBI) scoping review framework and reported the findings according to PRISMA-ScR (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analysis-Scoping Reviews) reporting guidelines. An information specialist performed a comprehensive search from the date of inception until February 2020, in seven bibliographic databases: Cochrane Library, MEDLINE, EMBASE, Web of Science, Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature (CINAHL), ScienceDirect, and IEEE Xplore. The selected studies considered all populations who provide and receive care in CBPHC settings, AI interventions that had been implemented, tested, or both, and assessed outcomes related to patients, health care providers, or CBPHC systems. Risk of bias was assessed using the Prediction Model Risk of Bias Assessment Tool (PROBAST). Two authors independently screened the titles and abstracts of the identified records, read the selected full texts, and extracted data from the included studies using a validated extraction form. Disagreements were resolved by consensus, and if this was not possible, the opinion of a third reviewer was sought. A third reviewer also validated all the extracted data. Results: We retrieved 22,113 documents. After the removal of duplicates, 16,870 documents were screened, and 90 peer-reviewed publications met our inclusion criteria. Machine learning (ML) (41/90, 45%), natural language processing (NLP) (24/90, 27%), and expert systems (17/90, 19%) were the most commonly studied AI interventions. These were primarily implemented for diagnosis, detection, or surveillance purposes. Neural networks (ie, convolutional neural networks and abductive networks) demonstrated the highest accuracy, considering the given database for the given clinical task. The risk of bias in diagnosis or prognosis studies was the lowest in the participant category (4/49, 4%) and the highest in the outcome category (22/49, 45%). Conclusions: We observed variabilities in reporting the participants, types of AI methods, analyses, and outcomes, and highlighted the large gap in the effective development and implementation of AI in CBPHC. Further studies are needed to efficiently guide the development and implementation of AI interventions in CBPHC settings.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 103 references indexed in Scilit:
- A bioinformatics approach to identify patients with symptomatic peanut allergy using peptide microarray immunoassayJournal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology, 2012
- Miscoding, misclassification and misdiagnosis of diabetes in primary careDiabetic Medicine, 2011
- Scoping studies: advancing the methodologyImplementation Science, 2010
- Health Care Reform and Primary Care — The Growing Importance of the Community Health CenterNew England Journal of Medicine, 2010
- Data mining of tuberculosis patient data using multiple correspondence analysisEpidemiology and Infection, 2009
- An Expert System for Headache Diagnosis: The Computerized Headache Assessment Tool (CHAT)Headache: The Journal of Head and Face Pain, 2007
- Translating Research into Practice: Organizational Issues in Implementing Automated Decision Support for Hypertension in Three Medical CentersJournal of the American Medical Informatics Association, 2004
- Comparison of an expert system with other clinical scores for the evaluation of severity of asthmaEuropean Respiratory Journal, 1996
- An Expert System for Performance-based Direct Delivery of Published Clinical EvidenceJournal of the American Medical Informatics Association, 1996
- The potential for computer-aided diagnosis of tropical diseases in developing countries: An expert system case studyEuropean Journal of Operational Research, 1990