Feigned Consensus: Usurping the Law in Shaken Baby Syndrome/Abusive Head Trauma Prosecutions
Authors:
Preprint
- 4 February 2019
- preprint
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Abstract
Few medico-legal matters have generated as much controversy "both in the medical literature and in the courtroom" as Shaken Baby Syndrome (SBS), now known more broadly as Abusive Head Trauma (AHT). The controversies are of enormous significance in the law because child abuse pediatricians claim, on the basis of a few non-specific medical findings supported by a weak and methodologically flawed research base, to be able to "diagnose" child abuse, and thereby to provide all of the evidence necessary to satisfy all of the legal elements for criminal prosecution (or removal of children from their parents). It is a matter, therefore, in which medical opinion claims to fully occupy the legal field. As controversies flare up increasingly in the legal arena, child abuse pediatricians and prosecutors now respond by claiming both that there is actually no real controversy about SBS/AHT, and that it is a purely medical "diagnosis" and not a legal conclusion, so testimony in support of the SBS hypothesis should not be challenged in court. This article, coauthored by four law professors, two physicians, and a physicist, demonstrates that there is very much a live controversy about the SBS/AHT hypothesis and maintains that, under traditional principles of Evidence law, physicians should not be permitted to "diagnose" abuse in court (as opposed to identifying specific symptoms or medical findings).Keywords
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- Curated Decay by Caitlin DeSilvey, with commentaries by Emma Waterton, Harlan Morehouse, Richard Schein, Tim Cresswell and Caitlin DeSilveyCultural Geographies, 2017
- Editor's note on Zheng et al. and Rahmani et al.Nature Methods, 2017
- FBI confesses to hair mistakesNew Scientist, 2015
- Ethical Issues in Forensic Testimony Involving Abusive Head TraumaAcademic Forensic Pathology, 2013
- Derivation of a Clinical Prediction Rule for Pediatric Abusive Head Trauma*Pediatric Critical Care Medicine, 2013
- Seel, Richard or Johann Richard2011
- Shaken Baby Syndrome: A Genuine Battle of the Scientific (and Non-Scientific) ExpertsSSRN Electronic Journal, 2009
- Comparison of performance by otolaryngologists, pediatricians, and general practioners on an otoendoscopic diagnostic video examinationInternational Journal of Pediatric Otorhinolaryngology, 2005
- Diagnostic certainty for acute otitis mediaInternational Journal of Pediatric Otorhinolaryngology, 2002
- Ethical Priciples for Medical Research Involving Human Subjects: World Medical AssociationBiotechnology Law Report, 2001