Constitutional democracy is challenged from many sides. The challenge is not merely stemming from authoritarian affronts, pitting authoritarian regimes against liberal democracies, but in recent decades has come to include a distinctive “internal” challenge in the form of illiberal types of populism. A heightened interest in constitutions includes an exploration of constitutionalism beyond a strictly legal perspective, and an investigatory curiosity as to the broader bases and contextual dimensions of constitutional democracies. This not least includes attention for cultural and symbolic dimensions of constitutions. The chapter focuses on the emerging attention in legal and constitutional studies for the concept of constitutional imaginaries, identifying different understandings of the concept, teases out some tensions within the concept, and explores the possibility of shifts between imaginaries. In the final part, the chapter addresses a recently emerging “populist imaginary” in the context of constitutional democracy. Specific forms of populism are in stark contrast to some key assumptions and practices in modern, liberal constitutionalism. A core argument will be that populism unsettles hegemonic understandings of constitutionalism; hence we might be witnessing a potential shift in hegemonic understandings of what constitutionalism means.