A Delicate Balancing Act: Integrative Pluralism and the Pursuit of Unified Theories

Author:
Open Access
Publisher website
Google Scholar
Abstract
This paper examines the interplay between integrative explanatory pluralism and the quest for unified theories. We argue that when grounded in virtues associated with satisfactory explanations, integrative pluralism exhibits an inherent instability stemming from the conflict between the demand for unity and the commitment to preserving a patchwork of disparate partial explanations. A case study in cognitive science illuminates the challenges of maintaining both systematicity and depth in explanations within this framework. While this instability does not render integrative pluralism fundamentally flawed, it stresses the importance of a diachronic analysis of scientific dynamics and norms. The conclusion highlights the continued value of integrative pluralism in interdisciplinary research programs, while emphasizing its role as a temporary rather than permanent approach.
Funding Information
  • Narodowe Centrum Nauki (2014/14/E/HS1/00803)

This publication has 57 references indexed in Scilit: