Ups and downs of liquid-liquid transitions in GUV membranes from osmolarity and aspiration tensions
Preprint
Abstract
Lipid membranes undergo liquid-liquid phase separation to form micron-scale domains. Several physical parameters affect this phase transition. For example, a decrease in temperature causes membranes to demix, as does an increase in hydrostatic pressure. However, measurements to determine how tension affects membrane phase separation have yielded conflicting results. Experiments that have applied osmotic pressure differences to a population of vesicles have reported an increase in the membrane’s miscibility transition temperature. Conversely, experiments that have applied micropipette aspiration or substrate stretching to single membranes have reported a decrease. Here, we find that both osmotic pressure and micropipette aspiration can increase transition temperatures. We discuss how membrane pores and hidden areas in membranes present challenges to researchers seeking to quantitatively convert experimentally measured osmolarity differences into membrane tensions. We show that challenges of comparing data from different osmotic pressure experiments can be mitigated by renormalizing osmolarity differences, specifically by dividing by the exterior osmolarity. We discuss our results in the context of existing theoretical predictions and in light of four known effects of increasing tension on vesicle membranes: 1) a reduction in hidden area of tubes and aggregates, 2) a reduction in out-of-plane thermal fluctuations, 3) an increase in the area per lipid, and 4) the formation of pores. First, hidden area in tubes and other structures explains why vesicles appear to sustain high osmolarity differences. Next, changes in a membrane’s fluctuations and molecular area may explain shifts in miscibility transition temperatures. Finally, pores can explain time dependences. Overall, our results highlight the need for new theory, simulation, and experiments that unify predictions of how transition temperatures vary over all four regimes of membrane tension. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: Liquid-liquid phase separation occurs in artificial lipid membranes and in some natural membranes. Although there is consensus that applying tension to membranes should affect this phase transition, it is unclear whether tension should induce or suppress membrane phase separation, even in artificial membranes. Here, we show that two experimental methods of applying tension cause liquid domains to appear in membranes at constant temperature. We consider four different regimes of membrane tension. We introduce two speculative scenarios in which tension has nonmonotonic effects on membrane phase separation, and we evaluate the scenarios in context of current theory and experiments. We find that a scenario in which tension enhances and then suppresses phase separation is consistent with most (but not all) results.Keywords
Funding Information
- Chan Zuckerberg Biohub
This publication has 57 references indexed in Scilit:
- Depletion with Cyclodextrin Reveals Two Populations of Cholesterol in Model Lipid MembranesBiophysical Journal, 2016
- Front-to-Rear Membrane Tension Gradient in Rapidly Moving CellsBiophysical Journal, 2015
- Coarsening Dynamics of Domains in Lipid MembranesBiophysical Journal, 2013
- Minimal Effect of Lipid Charge on Membrane Miscibility Phase Behavior in Three Ternary SystemsBiophysical Journal, 2013
- Increasing Membrane Tension Decreases Miscibility Temperatures; an Experimental Demonstration via Micropipette AspirationBiophysical Journal, 2012
- Phase Behavior of Lipid Bilayers under TensionBiophysical Journal, 2012
- Seeing spots: Complex phase behavior in simple membranesBiochimica et Biophysica Acta (BBA) - Molecular Cell Research, 2005
- Permeability and the hidden area of lipid bilayersEuropean Biophysics Journal, 2004
- Spontaneous curvature of fluid vesicles induced by trans-bilayer sugar asymmetryEuropean Biophysics Journal, 1999
- The association of d-glucose with unilamellar phospholipid vesiclesBiophysical Chemistry, 1988