Forecasting language models are judged by accuracy, but how they use the news is rarely measured. We read the same questions with no evidence, with the real headlines and with unrelated placebo headlines, and, as controls, with one headline repeated and with headlines about a different event on the same topic. We use four open models from three families (7B to 120B parameters) and three proprietary frontier models. Open models over-update: headlines raise the mean forecast by 11–22 percentage points across four question sets, including a fresh set with registered predictions and independently written prediction-market questions, and by 15–21 points on 700 questions that were still open when read, a prospective test registered and externally timestamped in advance. Two label-free diagnostics derived from Bayesian updating flag the shift as excessive: treated as a prior and a posterior, the question-only and evidence forecasts should have equal means, and their movement should match the fall in uncertainty; neither holds. In the Qwen3 family the tested controls disfavour a volume-only account: repeating a headline lowers the push, paraphrases from other outlets add nothing to it, and same-topic headlines about other events produce a fifth of it (OLMo-2, by contrast, responds to same-topic coverage). The push needs headlines about the event, yet much of it is unrelated to the outcome (+0.20 on events that did not happen, +0.28 on those that did). In a limited test of three frontier models on 200 questions the push is smaller (6–10 points) and mostly tied to the outcome. Reading headlines one at a time and averaging halves the push without losing ranking skill. Auditing sixteen inference-time fixes and ten further rules on held-out questions, shrinking toward the base rate is the only family that passes our gate at the available power; with one consistent estimator, a measured gain beats a fixed halving clearly for Qwen3-32B and inconclusively for Qwen3-8B. Benchmarks built from headlines with open models therefore partly measure how far a model over-reads the news.