Hay, Mark, E.School of Biology, Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, GA 30332‐0230 USASeaweeds use defensive chemicals to deter a wide range of generalist consumers. Once seaweeds deter larger consumers like fishes and urchins, these seaweeds become sites of evolutionary opportunity for small, sedentary herbivores that escape or deter their own consumers by associating with toxic algae. In many cases, the compounds that deter fishes are the specific compounds that small, specialist herbivores use to locate or recognize their hosts. In numerous cases, it appears that “feeding” specialization is really “habitat” specialization, and is driven by the need for small sedentary herbivores to escape predation rather than by nutritional traits of the host. Similarly, palatable seaweeds can avoid herbivores by associating with unpalatable competitors; in some situations, palatable species may depend on defended competitors to prevent their local extinction due to herbivory. Seaweed chemical defenses also show strong geographic patterns (more in tropical than in temperate species), local patterns (more in herbivore‐rich than in herbivore‐poor sites), and within thallus patterns (concentrated in parts of the plant, or at times of the season or even day). Some intraspecific variance in defenses is caused by variance in physical stress (desiccation, UV) or induction of defenses following attack by small herbivores. In some cases, geographic variance is herbivore feeding choices, behavior, and evolution is driven by the indirect effects of seaweed defenses. Thus, chemical defenses often produce cascading effects that impact the ecology and evolution of marine systems as a whole.