How care divides and connects: On forest conflicts and transformations in a German upland region
Open Access
- 14 November 2026
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in People and Nature
Abstract
Forest conflicts require analysis in relation to diverse human–forest relationships specific to local contexts. We examine local forest conflicts from a critical care perspective, conceptualising care as deeply ambivalent and entangled with power. The analysis draws on empirical material from a case study in a German upland region, focusing on different practices of actively shaping and engaging with the forest. Diverse actors regard forest‐related practices as forms of care: a forester cares for young oak trees, a hiking trail warden cares for self‐made benches and shelters, an environmentalist cares for numerous species of lichen, and a nature conservation officer cares for the rarities in the forest. Care and conflict are deeply intertwined. Conflicts arise when actors use their personal understanding of care to justify their practices while criticising those of others. These conflicts are intensified by different facets of power enacted over humans and other‐than‐humans and by the dynamics through which care relationships shape actors' self‐perceptions. At the same time, a care perspective holds the potential to bridge divides and facilitate dialogue. By bringing attention to emotions, commitments and commonalities, it can foster mutual understanding, particularly within conflict settings. Analysing care practices elucidates human–forest relationships and improves current understanding of forest conflicts. As care inevitably involves ambivalence, power and exclusion, it is crucial to explore in depth what various actors perceive as ‘good care’. Moreover, care influences how actors understand themselves. Apart from its conflictive dimensions, care can contribute to mutual understanding by building bridges between diverse perspectives and practices. Read the free Plain Language Summary for this article on the Journal blog.This publication has 29 references indexed in Scilit:
- Caring with forests: Human and more‐than‐human care in forest occupations in GermanyPeople and Nature, 2026
- A social-ecological approach to local forest conflict analysis and shapingForest Policy and Economics, 2025
- Gesellschaftliche Naturverhältnisse – Grundbegriff und Denkraum für die Gestaltung von sozial-ökologischen Transformationen2024
- The concept of the human-forest relationship (HFR) – Definition and potentials for forest policy researchForest Policy and Economics, 2023
- Can nature conservation and wood production be reconciled in managed forests? A review of driving factors for integrated forest management in EuropeJournal of Environmental Management, 2020
- Caring for nature matters: a relational approach for understanding nature’s contributions to human well-beingCurrent Opinion in Environmental Sustainability, 2018
- The uncomfortable politics of care and conflict: Exploring nontraditional caring agenciesGeoforum, 2018
- Uncovering landscape values and micro-geographies of meanings with the go-along methodLandscape and Urban Planning, 2014
- Emotional conflicts in rational forestry: Towards a research agenda for understanding emotions in environmental conflictsForest Policy and Economics, 2013
- Some problems and possibilities of caringEthics, Place & Environment, 2010