Computer‐aided calibration for visual estimation of vegetation cover
- 26 October 2009
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Vegetation Science
- Vol. 20 (6) , 973-983
Abstract
Question: What precision and accuracy of visual cover estimations can be achieved after repeated calibration with images of vegetation in which the true cover is known, and what factors influence the results?Methods: Digital images were created, in which the true cover of vegetation was digitally calculated. Fifteen observers made repeated estimates with immediate feedback on the true cover. The effects on precision and accuracy through time were evaluated with repeated proficiency tests. In a field trial, cover estimates, before and after calibration, were compared with point frequency data.Results: Even a short time of calibration greatly improves precision and accuracy of the estimates, and can also reduce the influence of different backgrounds, aggregation patterns and experience. Experienced observers had a stronger tendency to underestimate the cover of narrow‐leaved grasses before calibration. The field trial showed positive effects of computer‐based calibration on precision, in that it led to considerably less between‐observer variation for one of the two species groups.Conclusions: Computer‐aided calibration of vegetation cover estimation is simple, self‐explanatory and time‐efficient, and might possibly reduce biases and drifts in estimate levels over time. Such calibration can also reduce between‐observer variation in field estimates, at least for some species. However, the effects of calibration on estimations in the field must be further evaluated, especially for multilayered vegetation.Keywords
This publication has 14 references indexed in Scilit:
- Comparison of data from two vegetation monitoring methods in semi-natural grasslandsEnvironmental Monitoring and Assessment, 2005
- Scale‐dependent variation in visual estimates of grassland plant coverJournal of Vegetation Science, 2003
- Ocular estimates of understory vegetation structure in a closed Picea glauca/Betula papyrifera forestJournal of Vegetation Science, 2000
- Digitized photographs in vegetation analysis ‐ a comparison of cover estimatesApplied Vegetation Science, 2000
- Comparison of field methods in vegetation monitoringWater, Air, & Soil Pollution, 1995
- Visual versus random-point percent cover estimations: 'objective' is not always betterMarine Ecology Progress Series, 1993
- Increasing the reliability of vegetation analyses by using a team of two investigatorsJournal of Vegetation Science, 1992
- Inter-observer variation in forest vegetation cover assessments.Silva Fennica, 1990
- A comparison of different sampling methods of quantitative vegetation analysisSilva Fennica, 1985
- Use of Visual Cover Assessments as Quantitative Estimators of Some British Woodland TaxaJournal of Ecology, 1983