Author misconduct: not just the editors' responsibility
Authors:
- 2 December 2004
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Medical Education
- Vol. 39 (1) , 83-89
Abstract
Background Researchers everywhere are under increasing pressure to publish in high quality journals. The amount of space available in a journal such as Medical Education has not kept pace with the rise in submissions. Against a background of fierce competition, authors sometimes cut corners. This may lead to misconduct. Aims This paper aims to explore the most common types of publication misconduct seen in the Medical Education editorial office, and to consider the reasons for this and the implications for researchers in the field. Discussion This paper looks at the work of the Committee on Publication Ethics and describes the type of routine, low level misconduct which is increasingly reported by its member journals, including Medical Education . We offer a list of authors' responsibilities as a way of drawing attention to the wide range of individuals affected by author misconduct. The paper outlines 7 representative cases of actual or potential misconduct which have been dealt with in the Medical Education editorial office during the 18‐month period to May 2004, putting them in context and using them to illustrate some of the ways in which apparently minor deviations from standard practice can have far reaching implications. Future directions This paper argues that misconduct affects a wider group than editors, although it is editors who are currently taking the lead in the promotion of standards. The authors suggest that responsibility for maintaining and improving standards in research publication should not be left to editors but should be seen as something in which all researchers have a stake. They support moves to make editors themselves more accountable to their readers and authors.Keywords
This publication has 9 references indexed in Scilit:
- Ringing the changes: some resolutions for the new year and beyondMedical Education, 2004
- Medical Education editorial policyMedical Education, 2004
- The role of academic journal publications in the UK Research Assessment ExerciseLearned Publishing, 2004
- Editorial misconductBMJ, 2003
- What happens to manuscripts submitted to the Journal?Medical Education, 1998
- Prevalence of Articles With Honorary Authors and Ghost Authors in Peer-Reviewed Medical JournalsJAMA, 1998
- EDITORIAL. From the new Editor: continuity and changeMedical Education, 1998
- Authorship is dying: long live contributorshipBMJ, 1997
- When authorship fails. A proposal to make contributors accountableJAMA, 1997