A multi‐centre randomized controlled trial comparing connective tissue graft with collagen matrix to increase soft tissue thickness at the buccal aspect of single implants: 1‐year results
- 20 July 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Clinical Periodontology
- Vol. 49 (9) , 911-921
Abstract
Aim: To compare connective tissue graft (CTG) with collagen matrix (CMX) in terms of increase in buccal soft tissue profile (BSP) at 1 year when applied at single implant sites.Materials and Methods: Patients with a single tooth gap in the anterior maxilla and horizontal mucosa defect were enrolled in a multi‐centre randomized controlled trial. All sites had a bucco‐palatal bone dimension of at least 6 mm, received a single implant and an immediate implant restoration using a full digital workflow. Sites were randomly allocated to the control (CTG) or test group (CMX) to increase buccal soft tissue thickness. The primary outcome was the increase in BSP at 1 year when compared with the pre‐operative situation based on superimposed digital surface models. The changes in BSP over time were registered at a buccal area of interest reaching from 0.5 mm below the soft tissue margin to 4 mm more apical. Secondary outcomes included patient‐reported, clinical and aesthetic outcomes.Results: Thirty patients were included per group (control: 50% females, mean age 50.1; test: 53% females, mean age 48.2). The increase in BSP at 1 year was 0.98 mm (98.3% confidence interval [CI]: 0.75–1.20) for CTG and 0.57 mm (98.3% CI: 0.34 to 0.79) for CMX. The mean difference of 0.41 mm (98.3% CI: 0.12 to 0.69) in favour of CTG was significant (p < .001). Based on an arbitrarily chosen threshold for success of 0.75 mm increase in BSP, 89.7% of the patients in the control group and 10% of the patients in the test group were successfully treated (odds ratio = 77.90; 95% CI: 13.52 to 448.80; p < .001). Sites treated with CMX demonstrated 0.89 mm (98.3% CI: 0.49 to 1.30) more shrinkage between postop and 1 year than sites treated with CTG. In addition, CMX resulted in significantly more marginal bone loss (0.39 mm; 95% CI: 0.05 to 0.74; p = .026) than CTG. There were no significant differences between the groups in terms of patients' aesthetic satisfaction (p = .938), probing depth (p = .917), plaque (p = .354), bleeding on probing (p = .783), midfacial recession (p = .915), Pink Esthetic Score (p = .121) and Mucosal Scarring Index (p = .965).Conclusions: CTG remains the gold standard to increase soft tissue thickness at implant sites. Clinicians need to outweigh the benefits of CMX against considerable resorption of the graft. This study was registered in ClinicalTrials.gov (NCT04210596).Keywords
Funding Information
- Osteology Foundation (18‐178)
- Universiteit Gent (BOF.STG.2019.0004.01)
This publication has 32 references indexed in Scilit:
- Soft tissue volume augmentation at dental implant sites using a volume stable three‐dimensional collagen matrix – histological outcomes of a preclinical studyJournal of Clinical Periodontology, 2017
- Randomized controlled clinical study evaluating effectiveness and safety of a volume‐stable collagen matrix compared to autogenous connective tissue grafts for soft tissue augmentation at implant sitesJournal of Clinical Periodontology, 2016
- Horizontal stability of connective tissue grafts at the buccal aspect of single implants: a 1‐year prospective case seriesJournal of Clinical Periodontology, 2015
- Biodegradation pattern and tissue integration of native and cross-linked porcine collagen soft tissue augmentation matrices – an experimental study in the ratHead & Face Medicine, 2014
- Efficacy of soft tissue augmentation around dental implants and in partially edentulous areas: a systematic reviewJournal of Clinical Periodontology, 2014
- A systematic review of post‐extractional alveolar hard and soft tissue dimensional changes in humansClinical Oral Implants Research, 2011
- Tissue integration of collagen‐based matrices: an experimental study in miceClinical Oral Implants Research, 2011
- Postoperative Complications Following Gingival Augmentation ProceduresJournal of Periodontology, 2006
- Evaluation of soft tissue around single‐tooth implant crowns: the pink esthetic scoreClinical Oral Implants Research, 2005
- The Plaque Control RecordJournal of Periodontology, 1972