Pentafecta assessment of enucleation techniques for infravesical obstruction in patients with large-volume benign prostatic hyperplasia

Authors:

Abstract
BACKGROUND:Comparative assessment of enucleative techniques for large-volume benign prostatic hyperplasia is traditionally limited to individual perioperative and functional endpoints, which precludes comprehensive evaluation. The pentafecta concept is a composite metric integrating technical success, hemostatic safety, complications, subjective improvement, and sexual function. It provides a patient-centered tool for holistic characterization of surgical outcomes. AIM:To evaluate outcomes of laparoscopic simple prostatectomy (LSP), ThuLEP, and HoLEP in patients with BPH 80 cm3using an adapted pentafecta criterion and to analyze reasons for its non-achievement. METHODS:A retrospective cohort study (n= 140): LSP (n= 51), ThuLEP (n= 41), HoLEP (n= 48). Pentafecta domains included: technical and functional success (residual prostate volume ≤30 mL, peak urinary flow rate ≥15 mL/s, post-void residual volume ≤50 mL); hemostatic safety (postoperative hemoglobin decrease ≤20 g/L, no blood transfusion); absence of significant lower urinary tract symptoms; subjective functional improvement (ΔIPSS ≥8, ΔQoL ≥2); and sexual function preservation (IIEF-5 ≥10, no retrograde ejaculation). Follow-up was 12 months. RESULTS:Pentafecta was achieved in 86.4% of cases. Excellent outcome rates (5 points): ThuLEP 70.7%, HoLEP 44.8%, LSP 39.2% (p= 0.01). Leading reasons for non-achievement: technical failure (~60%), insufficient hemostatic safety (~35%), sexual dysfunction (~13%), and lack of functional improvement (~13%). The complication domain was the least frequent reason for failure (~5%). CONCLUSION:Pentafecta is an informative and clinically applicable composite for benign prostatic hyperplasia surgery assessment, detecting inter-method differences invisible in single-endpoint analysis. The main bottlenecks are technical success and hemostatic safety. ThuLEP achieves the best overall pentafecta profile.

This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit: