Implementing result-based agri-environmental payments by means of modelling
Authors:
- Bartosz BartkowskiBBBartosz Bartkowski
- Nils DrosteNDNils Droste
- Mareike LießMLMareike Ließ
- William Sidemo-HolmWSWilliam Sidemo-Holm
- Ulrich WellerUWUlrich Weller
- Mark V. BradyMBMark V. Brady
Preprint
Abstract
From a theoretical point of view, result-based agri-environmental payments are clearly preferable to action-based payments. However, they suffer from two major practical disadvantages: costs of measuring the results and payment uncertainty for the participating farmers. In this paper, we propose an alternative design to overcome these two disadvantages by means of modelling (instead of measuring) the results. We describe the concept of model-informed result-based agri-environmental payments (MIRBAP), including a hypothetical example of payments for the protection and enhancement of soil functions. We offer a comprehensive discussion of the relative advantages and disadvantages of MIRBAP, showing that it not only unites most of the advantages of result-based and action-based schemes, but also adds two new advantages: the potential to address trade-offs among multiple policy objectives and management for long-term environmental effects. We argue that MIRBAP would be a valuable addition to the agri-environmental policy toolbox and a reflection of recent advancements in agri-environmental modelling.Keywords
All Related Versions
- Version 1, 2019-08-22, ArXiv
- Version 2, 2020-12-23, ArXiv
- Published version: Land Use Policy, 102.
This publication has 68 references indexed in Scilit:
- Herbicide free agriculture? A bio-economic modelling application to Swiss wheat productionAgricultural Systems, 2019
- DSS-Ecopay – A decision support software for designing ecologically effective and cost-effective agri-environment schemes to conserve endangered grassland biodiversityAgricultural Systems, 2018
- Classification and valuation of soil ecosystem servicesAgricultural Systems, 2016
- Should We Pay for Ecosystem Service Outputs, Inputs or Both?Environmental and Resource Economics, 2016
- Global Cost of Land Degradation2015
- Studies on Agri-environmental Measures: A Survey of the LiteratureEnvironmental Management, 2012
- Development of a simplistic vegetative filter strip model for sediment and nutrient retention at the field scaleHydrological Processes, 2009
- Designing payments for environmental services in theory and practice: An overview of the issuesEcological Economics, 2008
- Mitigation of greenhouse gas emissions in European conventional and organic dairy farmingAgriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, 2006
- Dynamic incentives by environmental policy instruments—a surveyEcological Economics, 2005