Refined Consolidation Settlement Calculation Based on the Oedometer Tests for Normally and Overconsolidated Clays

This study presents an enhanced analytical approach for one-dimensional consolidation settlement by introducing a revised AJOP (arc joint via optimum parameters) equation assuming creep and strain rate effects can be neglected for both normally and overconsolidated clays. This modified equation integrates both curved and linear segments within a unified framework, enhancing accuracy across varying stress levels for normally consolidated clay. Additionally, the revised AJOP function, coupled with newly proposed equations for symmetrical and asymmetrical hysteresis, improves the modeling of overconsolidated clay. The findings from a comparative investigation using benchmark datasets and conventional methods, including the linear function (LF) and the curved function (CF), reveal that the revised AJOP method was found to reduce settlement prediction errors by up to 85% compared to LF method (particularly at shallow layers) and by 10–15% compared to the CF method (particularly at deep layers). The revised AJOP equation effectively resolves this error with a wide range of depths. Furthermore, results highlight the crucial impact of clay layering techniques on consolidation settlement predictions. Non-layered models yield lower settlement estimates compared to multilayer approaches, emphasizing the significance of the proper $e-log{{\mathsf{\sigma }}^{\prime }}_v$ relationship and layering techniques in enhancing prediction reliability.