Open Mesh versus non-Mesh for groin hernia repair

Authors:

Abstract
Inguinal hernia repair is the most frequent operation in general surgery. Until recently the standard procedure has been open musculo‐aponeurotic repair using sutures under tension to close the defect but 'tension‐free' repair using prosthetic mesh is becoming increasingly common in many countries. The purpose of this review is to evaluate open mesh techniques in comparison with open non‐mesh techniques for the surgical repair of groin hernia. Electronic databases were searched and further trials were sought from the reference lists of reports of known trials. Through the EU Hernia Trialists Collaboration authors of identified randomised controlled trials were asked for information on any other trials known to them. There was no language restriction. Studies were eligible for inclusion if they were randomised or quasi‐randomised trials comparing either a) open mesh with open non‐mesh repair of groin hernia or b) open flat mesh repair with plug and mesh repair of groin hernia. For each outcome the results were derived using data from the best available source. The majority of data for this review came from individual patient data (IPD) supplied by the trialists. When these were unavailable data came from additional aggregated information or from published trial reports. All trials were analysed using the 'intention to treat' principle. Twenty trials comparing open mesh with open non‐mesh repair were identified. Open mesh methods, on average, took 7‐10 minutes less to perform than Shouldice procedures, but took 1‐4 minutes longer than other non‐mesh methods. There were no clear differences between mesh and non‐mesh groups for haematomas, seromas or wound/superficial infections. Three serious operative compications were reported after open mesh repair and three following non‐mesh repair. Overall, those in the mesh groups had a shorter length of hospital stay and quicker return to usual activities, but this pattern was not observed for all trials. There was a suggestion that persisting pain was less frequent after mesh repair than after non‐mesh repair but this result was dependent on one trial and data were not available for 11 trials. There was no evidence of a difference between the groups with respect to persisting numbness. Fewer hernia recurrences were reported after mesh repair (Peto OR: 0.37, 95% CI: 0.26 to 0.51). There were too few data to reliably address differential effects for patients with recurrent, bilateral or femoral hernias. Two trials comparing flat mesh with plug and mesh were identified. There was no clear evidence of differences between the groups. There is evidence that the use of open mesh repair is associated with a reduction in the risk of recurrence of between 50% and 75%. Although the trials were heterogenous there is also some evidence of quicker return to work and of lower rates of persisting pain following mesh repair. 開放式網膜和非網膜對於鼠蹊部疝氣的治療功效 腹股溝疝氣的治療是一般外科中常見的手術,至到最近,標準治療方法已經由使用在張力下緊貼著傷口進行縫合的開放式肌肉腱膜(open musculoaponeurotic repair)治療,轉換為使用人工網膜的無張力治療方法,並在許多國家都已經成為普遍使用的治療方法 本研究的主要目的在於評估開放式網膜技術和開放式非網膜技術對於鼠蹊部疝氣治療手術的影響 本研究針對電子資料庫進行搜尋,並且更進一步由已知試驗其文獻報告中的參考資料清單進行搜尋,也會對於經確認的試驗以詢問歐盟疝氣試驗研究委員會作者的方式來取得他們已知的其他資訊,本研究的搜尋範圍並沒有語言的限制 如果搜尋到的試驗是隨機性試驗或是類隨機性試驗並符合下列條件,便符合適於納入本研究的範圍;(A)該試驗係將開放式網膜和非開放式網膜對於鼠蹊部疝氣治療的比較,(B)該試驗係將開放式人工平網治療與人工網塞治療對於鼠蹊部疝氣的治療效果進行比較 對於每一個試驗結果都會將資料由最佳可用來源的數據來分析,本研究的主要數據使取自由試驗者所提供的個別患者數據(IPD),當這些無法使用的數據是取自額外的集合性資訊或是公開試驗報告時,所有的試驗都會依據「意圖治療」的原則進行進一步分析 有20個針對開放性網膜和非開放性網膜的治療效果進行比較,開放性網膜組平均而言花費大約,比Shouldice手術所需的時間還短7至10分鐘,但是卻比一般非網膜手術長了約1至4分鐘,在使用網膜和不使用網膜來治療的組別中,對於出現血腫(haematomas)、血清腫(seromas)或傷口/表面感染(wound/superficial infections)的機率並沒有顯著差異,在使用開放性網膜治療的組別中,有發現3個嚴重的手術併發症,而不使用網膜進行治療的組別也出現了3個嚴重併發症,整體來說,接受人工網膜治療的患者所需的住院時間較短,並且較快恢復至一般活動的機能,但是這樣的結果並沒有在所有試驗中出現,有一個推論是,在接受網膜治療後,受試者會比接受非網膜治療的患者少出現持續性疼痛現象,但是這個結果只出現在一個試驗中,且在其他11個試驗中並無法使用這樣的數據,目前並沒有證據顯示針對持續性麻痺有出現差異,在接受網膜治療後,較少患者會出現疝氣復發現象(Peto OR值為0.37,95%的信心區間介於0.26至0.51之間),目前的數據仍太少無法明確的區分對於患者疝氣復發、雙側型疝氣或股疝氣的影響,有2個試驗針對平板網膜和人工網塞的差異進行比較,但是無法獲得明確的數據來說明這兩種治療方法之間的差異...

This publication has 21 references indexed in Scilit: