Porcine Tibia is a Poor Substitute for Human Cadaver Tibia for Evaluating Interference Screw Fixation
- 1 April 2004
- journal article
- clinical trial
- Published by SAGE Publications in The American Journal of Sports Medicine
- Vol. 32 (3) , 765-771
Abstract
Background: Animal tissues are commonly used in anterior cruciate ligament graft fixation studies. Hypothesis: Porcine bones and tendons provide good surrogates for human cadaver tissues in the biomechanical evaluation of anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Study Design: Randomized experimental study. Method: Three different tissue models—pure porcine (porcine graft fixed in porcine tibia, group 1), combination (human hamstring graft and porcine tibia, group 2), and pure human (human graft and tibia, group 3)—were compared using both cyclicloading and subsequent single-cycle load-to-failure tests to assess the effect of graft and bone tissue source (porcine vs human) on the fixation strength of anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Results: In the cyclic-loading test, the displacement (slippage) after 1500 cycles was 2.0 mm ± 0.7 mm, 1.6 mm ± 0.4 mm, and 4.4 mm ± 1.9 mm for groups 1, 2, and 3, respectively (P< .001 between 1 and 2 vs 3). In the subsequent single-cycle load-tofailure test, the corresponding average yield loads were 668 N ± 157 N, 962 N ± 238 N, and 448 N ± 98 N, all differences being statistically significant. Conclusions: In comparison to young human cadaver tibia, porcine tibia underestimate graft slippage and overestimate the failure load of the soft tissue graft in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction. Clinical Relevance: Porcine tibia does not provide a reasonable surrogate for human cadaver tibia for evaluating ACL reconstructions.Keywords
This publication has 53 references indexed in Scilit:
- Inaccuracies Inherent in Dual-Energy X-Ray Absorptiometry In Vivo Bone Mineral Density Can Seriously Mislead Diagnostic/Prognostic Interpretations of Patient-Specific Bone FragilityJournal of Bone and Mineral Research, 2001
- Inaccuracies Inherent in Patient-Specific Dual-Energy X-Ray Absorptiometry Bone Mineral Density Measurements: Comprehensive Phantom-Based EvaluationJournal of Bone and Mineral Research, 2001
- A Physical Model for Dual-Energy X-Ray Absorptiometry–Derived Bone Mineral DensityInvestigative Radiology, 2000
- Peripheral Quantitative Computed Tomography in Human Long Bones: Evaluation of In Vitro and In Vivo PrecisionJournal of Bone and Mineral Research, 1998
- Fixation strength of a biodegradable interference screw and a press‐fit technique in anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction with a BPTB graftArthroscopy, 1997
- Noninvasive assessment of bone mineral and structure: State of the artJournal of Bone and Mineral Research, 1996
- Comparison of Failure Strength Between Metallic and Absorbable Interference ScrewsThe American Journal of Sports Medicine, 1996
- Anterior Cruciate Ligament Graft FixationThe American Journal of Sports Medicine, 1994
- The biomechanics of interference screw fixation of patellar tendon anterior cruciate ligament graftsThe American Journal of Sports Medicine, 1993
- Effects of freezing and freeze‐drying on the biomechanical properties of rat boneJournal of Orthopaedic Research, 1983