A Comparison of diagnostic performance of CT with rectal contrast vs. CT with rectal and intravenous contrast for the diagnosis of acute appendicitis
Open Access
- 29 December 2025
- journal article
- Published by SJORANM GmbH in Swiss Journal of Radiology and Nuclear Medicine
- Vol. 26 (1) , 17-30
Abstract
Aim: Computed tomography (CT) is an essential investigation for the evaluation of suspected acute appendicitis (AA) owing to its high accuracy and the ability to provide an alternate diagnosis, however, there is still debate on the optimal CT technique with protocols varying between institutions. The present study aimed to compare the diagnostic accuracy of CT with rectal contrast (CT-RC) with that of CT with both rectal and intravenous contrast (CT-IVRC) in the diagnosis of AA. Material and methods: CTs of 135 patients were analysed by 2 radiologists retrospectively. Clinical outcome was used as the final diagnosis. The diagnostic accuracy of each CT technique was calculated and compared with each other. Results: There was strong agreement inter- and intra-observer agreement for the diagnosis of AA (kappa= 0.76, 0.87, 0.89 and 0.91 for CT-RC and CT-IVRC, respectively). The sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value, negative predictive value and diagnostic accuracy of CT-RC and CT-IVRC for the diagnosis of AA were not statistically different from each other (p-value>0.05 for all comparisons). The accuracy of two CT protocols in diagnosing AA ranged from 82% to 88%. The area under the curves (AUC) for diagnosing AA on CT-RC and CT-IVRC for two observers were 0.87. 0.9, 0.89 and 0.91 respectively. Conclusions: CT-RC proved to be as accurate as CT-IVRC in the diagnosis of AA. CT with rectal contrast alone could be performed in suspected cases of AA particularly in patients with contraindications to intravenous contrast administration. -------------------------------------------------------------------- Introduction Acute appendicitis (AA) constitutes one of the im-portant causes of abdominal pain and is a frequent reason for emergency department (ED) visits. AA is the most common cause of hospitalization in young patients presenting with acute abdomen (1). AA has an estimated annual occurrence of 5.7–50 per 100,000 population per year with a peak incidence between the age of 10 -30 years (1). The clinical data and laboratory information may not be always sufficient to diagnose or exclude AA or to provide an alternative diagnosis. Although appendectomy has been the standard of care for the management of AA, recently there has been a gradual shift towards conservative management of AA (2-3). However, before a firm management decision is made it is essential to establish a confident diagnosis of AA. Imaging comprising of ultrasonography (US), computed tomography (CT), and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) all can be used to clinch the diagnosis of AA (3). US is the preliminary diagnostic tool (4). However, abdominal CT has superseded US for the evaluation of suspected AA in most centres owing to its high accuracy and the ability to provide an alternate diagnosis in non-appendicitis patients (5). It has been observed that CT decreases the negative appendectomy rates without increasing the rate of AA-related complications like perforation or peritonitis (6). MRI is reserved for specific clinical scenarios where the US may be unable to provide a diagnosis and CT is contraindicated like in pregnancy (7, 8). The debate for the selection of optimal CT technique in the evaluation of suspected AA is still unresolved and different centres opt for different protocols (5). CT with administration of both intravenous (IV) and positive oral contrast has been the traditional technique with arguably the highest diagnostic yield (5, 9). The widespread use of this technique was based on the premise that this is the standard body imaging technique capable of maximising the visualisation of the appendix and allowing for the identification of extra-appendiceal pathologies (5). Despite its remarkably high accuracy for diagnosing AA, this technique is not necessarily the optimal or safest technique. Administration of IV contrast is fraught with many potential risks including the risk of anaphylactic reactions, risk of contrast-induced nephropathy (CIN), potential risk of extravasation and increased cost (10). The use of positive oral contrast is associated with time delays as it requires the passage of contrast to the caecum (11). The alternative protocols used by different centres across the world include IV contrast alone, positive oral contrast alone, rectal contrast alone, both IV and rectal contrast and no use of contrast (12-17). The use of positive oral contrast and rectal contrast can aid in the easy detection of the appendix when the caecum and terminal ileum are opacified with contrast and secondly, filling of the lumen of an appendix with contrast essentially rules out appendicitis (5). Positive oral contrast is associated with a time delay of approximately 1-2 hours which is the usual transit time and secondly, in 18-30% of patients the contrast fails to reach the caecum (5). Additionally, oral contrast will not be tolerated by patients with nausea or vomiting. Rectal contrast is associated with shorter delays of around 20 minutes and acceptable levels of patient discomfort (18). The use of rectal contrast-enhanced CT (CT-RC) has been studied in isolation and has been found useful with a sensitivity of 98% and a diagnostic accuracy of 98% (19). However, a direct comparison between CT-RC and rectal contrast plus IV contrast-enhanced CT (CT-IVRC) is lacking. The purpose of this study was to compare the diagnostic accuracy of CT-RC with that of CT-IVRC in the diagnosis of AA. Methods Study design and patient cohort This was a single-centre retrospective cross-sectional analytical study conducted for a period of one year, between January 2020 to December 2020. The study was approved by the institutional research committee. Due to the retrospective nature of the study, the requirement for patient consent was waived. One hundred thirty-five patients who presented to ED with abdominal pain with a clinical suspicion of AA and underwent abdominal CT with both rectal and IV contrast were...Keywords
This publication has 21 references indexed in Scilit:
- A Randomized Trial Comparing Antibiotics with Appendectomy for AppendicitisNew England Journal of Medicine, 2020
- Antibiotics-First Versus Surgery for Appendicitis: A US Pilot Randomized Controlled Trial Allowing Outpatient Antibiotic ManagementAnnals of Emergency Medicine, 2017
- Intravenous contrast alone vs intravenous and oral contrast computed tomography for the diagnosis of appendicitis in adult ED patientsThe American Journal of Emergency Medicine, 2012
- Imaging utilization in the management of appendicitis and its impact on hospital chargesEmergency Radiology, 2007
- Focused Helical CT Using Rectal Contrast Material Only as the Preferred Technique for the Diagnosis of Suspected Acute Appendicitis: A Prospective, Randomized, Controlled Study Comparing Three Different TechniquesDiseases of the Colon & Rectum, 2007
- Rapid CT diagnosis of acute appendicitis with IV contrast materialEmergency Radiology, 2005
- The value of contrast-enhanced helical CT scan with rectal contrast enema in the diagnosis of acute appendicitisClinical Imaging, 2005
- Advantages of Focused Helical Computed Tomographic Scanning With Rectal Contrast Only vs Triple Contrast in the Diagnosis of Clinically Uncertain Acute AppendicitisArchives of Surgery, 2004
- The value of limited computed tomography with rectal contrast in the diagnosis of acute appendicitisThe American Journal of Surgery, 2000
- Introduction of Appendiceal CTAnnals of Surgery, 1999