‘ Ceci N’est Pas Une Fouille À Corps ’: The Denial of Strip Searches in Belgian Prisons
Author:
- Tom DaemsTDTom Daems
- 16 October 2014
- book chapter
- Published by Emerald Publishing
- p. 75-94
Abstract
Purpose: This chapter reconstructs and critically examines the recent history of strip searches in Belgium. About 10 years ago the Belgian parliament adopted its first law on prisoners’ rights. A major part of the Prison Act of 12 January 2005 deals with disciplinary and control measures. Article 108, in particular, has provoked quite some controversy. It introduced a clear distinction between the (more superficial) search of an inmates’ clothes on the one hand, and the (substantially more intrusive) measure of strip searching on the other hand. The main difference between these two measures is that the latter involves forcing prisoners to strip naked. Because of their intrinsic intrusiveness, such strip searches were meant to be exceptional measures: they should only take place following an individual assessment and decision by the prison governor. In practice, however, the prison administration tended to interpret Article 108 somewhat differently and the line between searching an inmate’s clothes on the one hand and strip searching on the other became blurred. Design/methodology/approach: I first discuss the problem of order in prisons and explore how strip searches have been regulated in Europe. I then reconstruct the recent history of the regulation of strip searches in Belgium. In order to make sense of this history, I mobilize some of the ideas of Stanley Cohen’s sociology of denial, in particular, his distinction between literal, implicatory and interpretive denial, and apply these to the history of strip searches in Belgium. Findings: A consistent finding from this chapter is that the Belgian prison administration has – through creative manoeuvres of interpretive denial – been able to circumvent the new barriers that were erected by the Prison Act of 12 January 2005 and, in doing so, it has been able to continue stripping detainees naked without an individualized decision from the prison governor. The approach that I develop throughout this chapter helps us better appreciate the limits of legal reform and top-down (European) regulation of strip searches. Originality/value: The chapter demonstrates that Stanley Cohen’s work on denial is not only useful for scholars who do research on gross human rights violations but also for interpreting more down-to-earth aspects of criminal justice systems across the globe.Keywords
This publication has 12 references indexed in Scilit:
- Crime, criminal justice and criminology in BelgiumEuropean Journal of Criminology, 2013
- From Prison Sentence to Deprivation of Liberty A Brief History of Two Centuries of Legal Regulation of the Belgian Prison Regime (1795–2006)European Journal of Crime, Criminal Law and Criminal Justice, 2012
- Moral performance, inhuman and degrading treatment and prison painPunishment & Society, 2011
- Penal Policy and Practice in BelgiumCrime and Justice, 2007
- La prison post-disciplinaireDéviance et Société, 2006
- La nouvelle loi pénitentiaire.Courrier Hebdomadaire du CRISP, 2006
- Government Responses to Human Rights Reports: Claims, Denials, and CounterclaimsHuman Rights Quarterly, 1996
- Prisons and the Problem of Order1996
- State Crimes of Previous Regimes: Knowledge, Accountability, and the Policing of the PastLaw & Social Inquiry, 1995
- Human Rights and Crimes of The State: The Culture of DenialAustralian & New Zealand Journal of Criminology, 1993