A major challenge in thermospheric modeling is characterizing the neutral density response to geomagnetic storms, which is crucial for spacecraft safety in low Earth orbit (LEO). We study the neutral density response to 278 geomagnetic storms from 2010-2024 driven by high-speed streams/stream interaction regions (HSS/SIR) and interplanetary coronal mass ejection (ICME) sheaths and magnetic clouds (MC) using the Swarm, GRACE, and GRACE-FO satellites. To conduct a statistical analysis across varying LEO altitudes and solar cycle phases, a novel method is introduced to calculate the relative change in orbit-averaged neutral density, altitude-adjusted to 450 km. The method captures density changes caused by geomagnetic activity and is purely data-based. Superposed epoch analysis shows that MC-driven storms cause the largest peak neutral density enhancements, with a median superposed value of 130% above the quiet-time density. Sheath-driven storms exhibit the fastest density increases but have the shortest main phases, resulting in the least cumulative density change over the entire storm. HSS/SIR storms have the longest-lasting neutral density enhancements, leading to a cumulative effect that is almost equal to that of MC storms, despite having a lower peak density enhancement (116%). Comparison with northern hemispheric Joule heating estimates reveals that prolonged intervals of intense Joule heating cause these large density changes, with MC storms having significantly more cumulative heating than HSS/SIR or sheath storms. However, Joule heating most efficiently causes density enhancements during HSS/SIR storms, and these enhancements have a longer recovery half-life (15.3h) than for MCs (9.4h) or sheaths (7.7h).