Continuous spinal anaesthesia or continuous epidural anaesthesia for post-operative pain control after hip replacement?
Authors:
- D. HolstDHD. Holst
- 1 July 1999
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in European Journal of Anaesthesiology
- Vol. 16 (7) , 454-461
Abstract
Both continuous spinal anaesthesia and continuous epidural anaesthesia are supposed to provide adequate post-operative pain relief. The purpose of this randomized, prospective study was to compare the quality of analgesia, occurence of side effects and patient satisfaction between spinal and epidural administration of bupivacaine during the first post-operative 72 h. One hundred and two patients scheduled for hip arthroplasty were randomly assigned to one of two groups: Group 1 received continuous spinal anaesthesia for intra-operative and post-operative management, Group 2 received continuous epidural anaesthesia. Immediately after surgery, the continuous spinal anaesthesia-group received a 1-mL bolus (bupivacaine 0.25%), followed by a continuous infusion of 10 mL over 24 h. The continuous epidural anaesthesia-group received a 10-mL bolus (bupivacaine 0.25%), followed by 2 mL h−1. The level of pain was gauged from a verbal rating score and from a visual analogue scale; the degree of motor blockade was recorded using the Bromage score. In the continuous spinal anaesthesia-group 90.2% reported complete analgesia on the verbal rating scale, but only 21.6% of the continous epidural anaesthesia-group did. The visual analogue scale scores given by the continuous spinal anaesthesia-group were significantly lower than those of the continuous epidural anaesthesia-group. The percentage of patients with a motor block was significantly higher in the continuous spinal anaesthesia-group on the day of surgery and at the first post-operative day. During the first 24 h, nausea and vomiting occured more often in the continuous epidural anaesthesia-group. The satisfaction was considered excellent in 92.2% of the continuous spinal anaesthesia-group and in 70.6% of the continuous epidural anaesthesia-group. It is concluded that continuous spinal anaesthesia and continuous epidural anaesthesia are effective and safe for post-operative pain relief after hip replacement. Compared with continuous epidural anaesthesia, continuous spinal anaesthesia provides faster onset of pain relief, ensures better analgesia and results in more satisfied patients.Keywords
This publication has 14 references indexed in Scilit:
- Die kontinuierliche SpinalanästhesieDer Anaesthesist, 1997
- Assessment of postoperative pain: impact of clinical experience and professional roleActa Anaesthesiologica Scandinavica, 1997
- Continuous regional analgesia in comparison with intravenous opioid administration for routine postoperative pain controlAnaesthesia, 1994
- Postoperative pain relief—what is the issue?British Journal of Anaesthesia, 1994
- COMPARISON OF CONTEMPORANEOUS AND RETROSPECTIVE ASSESSMENT OF POSTOPERATIVE PAIN USING THE VISUAL ANALOGUE SCALEBritish Journal of Anaesthesia, 1991
- Introducing an acute pain serviceAnaesthesia, 1991
- The Subjective Experience of Acute Pain An Assessment of the Utility of 10 IndicesThe Clinical Journal of Pain, 1989
- Comparison of continuous spinal and continuous epidural anaesthesia for lower limb surgery in elderly patients A retrospective studyAnaesthesia, 1989
- Development of an Anesthesiology-based Postoperative Pain Management ServiceAnesthesiology, 1988
- Pain on a surgical ward: a survey of the duration and intensity of pain and the effectiveness of medicationPain, 1987