Finding Medical Photographs of Patients Online: Randomized, Cross-Sectional Study (Preprint)
Authors:
- Zack MarshallZMZack Marshall
- Maushumi BhattacharjeeMBMaushumi Bhattacharjee
- Meng WangMWMeng Wang
- Abdul CadriACAbdul Cadri
- Hannah JamesHJHannah James
- Shabnam AsghariSAShabnam Asghari
- Rene PeltekianRPRene Peltekian
- Veronica BenzVBVeronica Benz
- Vanessa Finley-RoyVFVanessa Finley-Roy
- Brynna ChildsBCBrynna Childs
- Lauren AsaadLALauren Asaad
- Michelle SwabMSMichelle Swab
Preprint
- 13 December 2023
- preprint
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Preprints
Abstract
BACKGROUND Photographs from medical case reports published in academic journals have previously been found in online image search results. This means that patient photographs circulate beyond the original journal website and can be freely accessed online. While this raises ethical and legal concerns, no systematic study has documented how often this occurs. OBJECTIVE The aim of this cross-sectional study was to provide systematic evidence that patient photographs from case reports published in medical journals appear in Google Images search results. Research questions included the following: (1) what percentage of patient medical photographs published in case reports were found in Google Images search results? (2) what was the relationship between open access publication status and image availability? and (3) did the odds of finding patient photographs on third-party websites differ between searches conducted in 2020 and 2022? METHODS The main outcome measure assessed whether at least 1 photograph from each case report was found on Google Images when using a structured search. Secondary outcome variables included the image source and the availability of images on third-party websites over time. The characteristics of medical images were described using summary statistics. The association between the source of full-text availability and image availability on Google Images was tested using logistic regressions. Finally, we examined the trend of finding patient photographs using generalized estimating equations. RESULTS From a random sample of 585 case reports indexed in PubMed, 186 contained patient photographs, for a total of 598 distinct images. For 142 (76.3%) out of 186 case reports, at least 1 photograph was found in Google Images search results. A total of 18.3% (110/598) of photographs included eye, face, or full body, including 10.9% (65/598) that could potentially identify the patient. The odds of finding an image from the case report online were higher if the full-text paper was available on ResearchGate (odds ratio [OR] 9.16, 95% CI 2.71-31.02), PubMed Central (OR 7.90, 95% CI 2.33-26.77), or Google Scholar (OR 6.07, 95% CI 2.77-13.29) than if the full-text was available solely through an open access journal (OR 5.33, 95% CI 2.31-12.28). However, all factors contributed to an increased risk of locating patient images online. Compared with the search in 2020, patient photographs were less likely to be found on third-party websites based on the 2022 search results (OR 0.61, 95% Cl 0.43-0.87). CONCLUSIONS A high proportion of medical photographs from case reports was found on Google Images, raising ethical concerns with policy and practice implications. Journal publishers and corporations such as Google are best positioned to develop an effective remedy. Until then, it is crucial that patients are adequately informed about the potential risks and benefits of providing consent for clinicians to publish their images in medical journals.Keywords
All Related Versions
- Published version: Journal of Medical Internet Research, 26, e55352.
This publication has 11 references indexed in Scilit:
- PMIDigest: Interactive Review of Large Collections of PubMed Entries to Distill Relevant InformationGenes, 2023
- Algorithmic probing: Prompting offensive Google results and their moderationBig Data & Society, 2023
- Publishing Identifiable Patient Photographs in Scientific Journals: Scoping Review of Policies and PracticesJournal of Medical Internet Research, 2022
- What Patients, Students and Doctors Think About Permission to Publish Patient Photographs in Academic Journals: A Cross-Sectional Survey in CroatiaScience and Engineering Ethics, 2019
- Open Availability of Patient Medical Photographs in Google Images Search Results: Cross-Sectional Study of Transgender ResearchJournal of Medical Internet Research, 2018
- Herpes simplex transmission to chest and face through autoinoculation in an infantBMJ Case Reports, 2017
- Accidental Technologist: The Tor Browser and Intellectual Freedom in the Digital AgeReference & User Services Quarterly, 2015
- Bias in algorithmic filtering and personalizationEthics and Information Technology, 2013
- Practical guide to understanding the value of case reportsOtolaryngology–Head and Neck Surgery, 2008
- The Strengthening the Reporting of Observational Studies in Epidemiology (STROBE) statement: guidelines for reporting observational studiesThe Lancet, 2007