Voluntary vs Compulsory Playing Contexts: Motivational, Cognitive, and Game Experience Effects
- 26 October 2016
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Simulation & Gaming
- Vol. 48 (1) , 36-55
Abstract
Background. Serious games are often used in formal school contexts, in which students’ lack of control over the playing situation may have repercussions on any motivational gains. Aims and Method. The first aim was to investigate to what extent n = 579 fifth grade students in Mexico who received a mathematics serious game played it voluntarily. Then, we explored how students who played voluntarily ( n = 337) differed from those who did not by either gender or pre-test mathematical skills or motivation. The second aim was to find out whether two play contexts, the group of voluntary players and a second group consisting of students playing at school as a compulsory part of their regular mathematics lessons ( n = 482), differed in game experience, game performance, and cognitive and motivational outcomes. Results. Students from the volunteer group who played had higher pre-test mathematical skills and math interest than those who did not play. Students in this group did not otherwise differ. Compared to students from the volunteer group who played, students in the school group played for longer, completed more tasks, and enjoyed playing the game more. However, their advanced mathematical skills did not improve as much. Conclusion. Motivation did not improve regardless of play context, suggesting serious games should be implemented for their learning content rather than because they are assumed to be motivating.Keywords
This publication has 34 references indexed in Scilit:
- Motivation and students’ use of learning strategies: Evidence of unidirectional effects in mathematics classroomsLearning and Instruction, 2011
- Game Engagement Theory and Adult LearningSimulation & Gaming, 2010
- User Experience in Digital GamesSimulation & Gaming, 2010
- Students’ perceptions about the use of video games in the classroomComputers & Education, 2010
- Predictors of creative computing participation and profiles of experience in two Silicon Valley middle schoolsComputers & Education, 2010
- Expectancy-value theory: retrospective and prospective2010
- Concept–procedure interactions in children’s addition and subtractionJournal of Experimental Child Psychology, 2009
- Why can't Johnny remember the basic facts?Developmental Disabilities Research Reviews, 2009
- The Four-Phase Model of Interest DevelopmentEducational Psychologist, 2006
- The "What" and "Why" of Goal Pursuits: Human Needs and the Self-Determination of BehaviorPsychological Inquiry, 2000