Abstract
The recent article in Journal of Clinical Epidemiology by Schmidt et al. contains a number of errors that lead to some sweeping conclusions. These sweeping conclusions are best summarized in the title: “Treatment Effects in Pharmacological Clinical Randomized Controlled Trials are Mainly Due to Placebo”. This claim is made on the basis that the within-arm change scores of treatment and placebo arms correlate across 150 RCTs from 5 clinical domains. These conclusions reflect a misunderstanding of what a “treatment effect” is and a misinterpretation of the importance of the relationship between within-arm changes.