“… And How About Now?”: Effects of Item Redundancy on Contextualized Self-Reports of Personality
- 26 September 2011
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Personality
- Vol. 79 (5) , 1081-1112
Abstract
A common method of studying cross‐situational variation in personality involves asking people to describe their behavior in several different contexts. Although this approach is intuitively appealing, it introduces a great deal of redundancy into the measurement process and may affect the interpretation of contextualized self‐reports. Specifically, when participants are asked the same questions repeatedly in a single questionnaire, they may be compelled to focus on how their behavior is different. We tested this hypothesis by experimentally manipulating the number of contexts that were included in a measure of role‐related personality. In 2 experiments (Study 1 N=377, Study 2 N=524), we found that multiple‐role questionnaires produced greater variation in trait levels across roles, larger differences between general and role‐specific ratings, and weaker correlations between general and role‐specific ratings than single‐role questionnaires. These findings illustrate how the measurement process can have an effect on the variability of responses to contextualized self‐reports.Keywords
This publication has 32 references indexed in Scilit:
- Contextualized Self‐Representations in AdulthoodJournal of Personality, 2007
- Contextualized Personality: Traditional and New Assessment ProceduresJournal of Personality, 2007
- Cross‐Sectional and Longitudinal Tests of the Personality and Role Identity Structural Model (PRISM)Journal of Personality, 2006
- On Traits, Situations, and Their Integration: A Developmental PerspectivePersonality and Social Psychology Review, 2004
- A field study of frame-of-reference effects on personality test validity.Journal of Applied Psychology, 2003
- The Patterned Inconsistency of Traits: Mapping the Differential Effects of Social Roles on Self-Perceptions of the Big FivePersonality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 1998
- Correlations redux.Psychological Bulletin, 1995
- One Personality, Multiple Selves: Integrating Personality and Social RolesJournal of Personality, 1994
- Verbal and Math Self-Concepts: An Internal/External Frame of Reference ModelAmerican Educational Research Journal, 1986
- Design and analysis of experiments contrasting the within- and between-subjects manipulation of the independent variable.Psychological Bulletin, 1977