Reply to Bhatt and Pancheva's “Late Merger of Degree Clauses”: The Irrelevance of (Non)conservativity
Authors:
- 1 July 2006
- journal article
- Published by MIT Press in Linguistic Inquiry
- Vol. 37 (3) , 457-483
Abstract
According to Bhatt and Pancheva (2004), two effects they attribute to degree constructions (obligatory extraposition effects and scope rigidity effects determined by the superficial position of degree phrases/clauses) can be given a unified analysis in terms of an extension of Fox and Nissenbaum's (1999) analysis of extraposition in conjunction with the nonconservativity of (certain) degree words. We show that, under full preservation of Bhatt and Pancheva's theoretical assumptions, their account faces at least three problems: (a) one of the phenomena they propose to unify, the one involving scope effects, does not exist; (b) (non)conservativity is irrelevant to obligatory extraposition effects; and (c) contrary to their tacit assumption, Trace Conversion is at most an optional procedure for DegP chains. We propose an alternative, nonsemantic treatment of obligatory extraposition effects, which subsumes them under an independently needed adjacency constraint on prehead modifiers. Furthermore, we note that the facts brought up here and in Bhatt and Pancheva 2004 call into question the quantificational approach to degree constructions.Keywords
This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit:
- Pre- and postverbal adverbials in OV and VOLingua, 2004
- Degree expressionsThe Linguistic Review, 2004
- Late Merger of Degree ClausesLinguistic Inquiry, 2004
- A Unified Theory of `Standard' and `Transparent' Free RelativesNatural Language & Linguistic Theory, 2003
- The Meaning of Too, Enough, and So... ThatNatural Language Semantics, 2003
- The (Dis)organization of the Grammar: 25 YearsLinguistics and Philosophy, 2002
- Quantifiers in Comparatives: A Semantics of Degree Based on IntervalsNatural Language Semantics, 2002
- Antecedent-Contained Deletion and the Copy Theory of MovementLinguistic Inquiry, 2002
- Head Movement and AdjacencyNatural Language & Linguistic Theory, 1998
- A semantic characterization of natural language determinersLinguistics and Philosophy, 1986