Revisiting the Authoritative–Dialogic Tension in Inquiry-Based Elementary Science Teacher Questioning
- 1 April 2015
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in International Journal of Science Education
- Vol. 37 (8) , 1182-1201
Abstract
Building on the ‘questioning-based discourse analytical’ framework developed by Singapore-based science educator and discourse analyst, Christine Chin, this study investigated the extent to which fifth-grade science teachers' use of questions with either an authoritative or dialogic orientation differentially restricted or expanded the quality and complexity of student responses in the USA. The author analyzed approximately 10 hours of classroom discourse from elementary science classrooms organized around inquiry-based science curricula and texts. Teacher questions and feedback were classified according to their dialogic orientation and contextually inferred structural purpose, while student understanding was operationalized as a dynamic interaction between cognitive process, syntacto-semantic complexity, and science knowledge type. The results of this study closely mirror Chin's and other scholars' findings that the fixed nature of authoritatively oriented questioning can dramatically limit students' opportunities to demonstrate higher order scientific understanding, while dialogically oriented questions, by contrast, often grant students the discursive space to demonstrate a greater breadth and depth of both canonical and self-generated knowledge. However, certain teacher questioning sequences occupying the ‘middle ground’ between maximal authoritativeness and dialogicity revealed patterns of meaningful, if isolated, instances of higher order thinking. Implications for classroom practice are discussed along with recommendations for future research.Keywords
Funding Information
- National Science Foundation (Grant DRL 1209309)
This publication has 24 references indexed in Scilit:
- Developing fluency in the mathematical register through conversation in a tenth-grade classroomEducational Studies in Mathematics, 2012
- ‘Didn't Get Expected Answer, Rectify It.’: Teaching science content in an elementary science classroom using hands-on activitiesInternational Journal of Science Education, 2012
- Initiation/Response/Follow‐Up, and Response to Intervention: Combining Two Models to Improve Teacher and Student PerformanceForeign Language Annals, 2011
- Moving out of IRF (Initiation‐Response‐Feedback): A Single Case AnalysisLanguage Learning, 2009
- Scientific discourse in three urban classrooms: The role of the teacher in engaging high school students in argumentationScience Education, 2009
- Learning from and responding to students' questions: The authoritative and dialogic tensionJournal of Research in Science Teaching, 2009
- Putting a Tool to Different Uses: A Reevaluation of the IRF Sequence1999
- Using Questioning to Guide Student ThinkingJournal of the Learning Sciences, 1997
- Reflective discourse: developing shared understandings in a physics classroomInternational Journal of Science Education, 1997
- Analyzing arguments in science classroom discourse: Can teachers' questions distort scientific authority?Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 1983