The Illusion of the Carbon Premium
Authors:
- Thijs Dingeman MarkwatTMThijs Dingeman Markwat
- Matthias Xaver HanauerMHMatthias Xaver Hanauer
- Laurens SwinkelsLSLaurens Swinkels
Preprint
- 10 March 2026
- preprint
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Abstract
Carbon that has not yet been emitted should not be used to predict stock returns. When emissions are not lagged, we closely replicate the positive carbon premium documented by Bolton and Kacperczyk (2021). Using only carbon emissions data available to investors at the time of portfolio formation, however, we find no positive relation between firms' absolute carbon emissions and stock returns. The reported carbon premium is therefore driven by a look-ahead bias, as estimated emissions are mechanically linked to future revenues when emissions data are not sufficiently lagged. We further show that regression-based estimates of the carbon premium are sensitive to skewed dependent variables and multicollinearity with standard controls. When greenness is measured by carbon intensity rather than absolute emissions, green firms have outperformed brown firms. We provide out-of-sample evidence for a positive green-minus-brown factor over the period 2020-2025, despite the strong performance of energy stocks during the first year of the Russia-Ukraine war. Unlike earlier periods, this recent outperformance is not driven by a further widening in the cost of capital of carbon-intensive firms.Keywords
This publication has 21 references indexed in Scilit:
- Where is the carbon premium? Global performance of green and brown stocksJournal of Climate Finance, 2022
- Dissecting green returnsJournal of Financial Economics, 2022
- Do investors care about carbon risk?Journal of Financial Economics, 2021
- Mean-variance optimization using forward-looking return estimatesReview of Quantitative Finance and Accounting, 2018
- Choosing factorsJournal of Financial Economics, 2018
- Corporate Environmental Responsibility and the Cost of Capital: International EvidenceJournal of Business Ethics, 2016
- Predicting market returns using aggregate implied cost of capitalJournal of Financial Economics, 2013
- Removing predictable analyst forecast errors to improve implied cost of equity estimatesReview of Accounting Studies, 2013
- The price of sin: The effects of social norms on marketsJournal of Financial Economics, 2009
- Expected EPS and EPS Growth as Determinantsof ValueReview of Accounting Studies, 2005