Comparison of the prognostic validity of three simplified consciousness assessment scales with the Glasgow Coma Scale
Open Access
- 9 June 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in European Journal of Trauma and Emergency Surgery
- Vol. 49 (5) , 2193-2202
Abstract
Background: Various tools simpler than the Glasgow Coma Scale (GCS) have been proposed for the assessment of consciousness. In this study, the validity of three coma scales [Simplified Motor Scale, Modified GCS Motor Response, and AVPU (alert, verbal, painful, unresponsive)] is evaluated for the recognition of coma and the prediction of short- and long-term mortality and poor outcome. The predictive validity of these scales is also compared to the GCS. Methods: Patients treated in the Department of Neurosurgery and the Intensive Care Unit in need of consciousness monitoring were assessed by four raters (two consultants, a resident and a nurse) using the GCS. The corresponding values of the simplified scales were estimated. Outcome was recorded at discharge and at 6 months. Areas Under the Receiver Operating Characteristic Curve (AUCs) were calculated for the prediction of mortality and poor outcome, and the identification of coma. Results: Eighty-six patients were included. The simplified scales showed good overall validity (AUCs > 0.720 for all outcomes of interest), but lower than the GCS. For the identification of coma and the prediction of long-term poor outcome, the difference was significant (p < 0.050) for all the ratings of the most experienced rater. The validity of these scales was comparable to the GCS only in predicting in-hospital mortality, but without this being consistent for all raters. Conclusion: The simplified scales showed inferior validity than the GCS. Their potential role in clinical practice needs further investigation. Thus, the replacement of the GCS as the main scale for consciousness assessment cannot be currently supported.Keywords
Funding Information
- Aristotle University of Thessaloniki
This publication has 43 references indexed in Scilit:
- Reduction in Non-Protein Respiratory Quotient Is Related to Overall Survival after Hepatocellular Carcinoma TreatmentPLOS ONE, 2013
- Cheerio, Laddie! Bidding Farewell to the Glasgow Coma ScaleAnnals of Emergency Medicine, 2011
- Validation of the Simplified Motor Score for the Prediction of Brain Injury Outcomes After TraumaAnnals of Emergency Medicine, 2007
- Further Validation of the FOUR Score Coma Scale by Intensive Care NursesMayo Clinic Proceedings, 2007
- A Comparison of Five Simplified Scales to the Out‐of‐hospital Glasgow Coma Scale for the Prediction of Traumatic Brain Injury OutcomesAcademic Emergency Medicine, 2006
- Validation of a new coma scale: The FOUR scoreAnnals of Neurology, 2005
- GCS and AVPU: The alphabet soup doesn't spell “C-O-M-A” in toxicologyAnnals of Emergency Medicine, 2005
- Comparison of consciousness level assessment in the poisoned patient using the alert/verbal/painful/unresponsive scale and the glasgow coma scaleAnnals of Emergency Medicine, 2004
- Interobserver agreement for the assessment of handicap in stroke patients.Stroke, 1988
- ASSESSMENT OF OUTCOME AFTER SEVERE BRAIN DAMAGE A Practical ScaleThe Lancet, 1975