“The Spectacle of Amish Attacking Amish”: Framing Dichotomies in News Coverage of a Religious Hate Crime
- 1 August 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by University of California Press in Journal of Religion and Popular Culture
- Vol. 36 (2) , 86-100
Abstract
This study employs qualitative textual analysis to examine framing dichotomies in mainstream local news coverage of a series of attacks on Amish residents in Ohio carried out by a breakaway Amish group in 2011. Using Stuart Hall’s understanding of narrative binaries and the anthropological concept of the other within the other, the study argues portrayals of both the victims and the perpetrators of those crimes employed common stereotypes of Amish groups. The study describes the negative consequences of the “good Other” representation applied to the victims of the crimes and argues for more nuanced news coverage of non-mainstream religious groups.Keywords
This publication has 25 references indexed in Scilit:
- The S-Word: Discourse, Stereotypes, and the American Indian WomanHoward Journal of Communications, 2010
- Mitt Romney's Religion: A Five Factor Model for Analysis of Media Representation of Mormon IdentityJournal of Media and Religion, 2010
- Lesbian Television Personalities—A Queer New SubjectThe Journal of American Culture, 2009
- Counterframing Public Dissent: An Analysis of Antiwar Coverage in the U.S. MediaCritical Studies in Media Communication, 2009
- Feminist international relations and women militants: case studies from Sri Lanka and KashmirCambridge Review of International Affairs, 2009
- “I know y'all think I'm pretty square, but tuh, I believe what I believe”: Images of Evangelicals in American FilmJournal of Media and Religion, 2008
- History and Its DiscontentsCurrent Anthropology, 2008
- Of Scripts and Scriptures: Why Plain People Perpetuate a Media FastThe Journal of American Culture, 2006
- ‘When your child grows up too fast’: Juvenation and the boundaries of the social in the news mediaContinuum, 1998
- Race and Poverty in America: Public Misperceptions and the American News MediaPublic Opinion Quarterly, 1996