The Accuracy Of Formulas Used To Assess Strength Loss Due To Decay In Trees

Authors:
  • BKBrian C.P. Kane
    Brian C.P. Kane
  • HRH. Dennis P. Ryan
    H. Dennis P. Ryan

Abstract
There are four formulas that arborists in the United States often use to assess the probability of tree failure. Although they are commonly referred to as “strength loss formulas,” three of the formulas (Wagener 1963; Coder 1989; Smiley and Fraedrich 1992) actually estimate the loss instem moment of inertia(ISTEM) to evaluate the probability of failure. The formulas estimate the loss inISTEMby modeling the stem and decay cross-sectional areas as concentric circles. For many trees with decay, however, neither the stem nor the decay cross-sectional areas resemble concentric circles, which may limit the formulas’ accuracy. The fourth formula (Mattheck and Breloer 1998) is based on the buckling strength of a cylinder; it also offers a measure of the probability of stem failure. To test how well the formulas estimate the loss inISTEM, we compared each formula’s estimates for loss inISTEMto the actual loss inISTEMthat we calculated using theparallel axis theorem, an engineering technique. Although the parallel axis theorem provides the actual loss inISTEM, it cannot be used in practice because an image of the tree’s cross-section is needed to apply it. Significant differences existed between two formulas’ (Wagener 1963; Coder 1989) estimates of loss inISTEMand the actual value. Each of the formulas misclassified some trees as to whether they exceeded the formula’s action threshold. When we calculated the actual loss inISTEMfor those trees, however, it was less than 33%. We present representative stem cross-sections for which the formulas did not accurately represent loss inISTEM.